Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Chessmaster for palm

Author: Roy Eassa

Date: 13:01:15 11/28/02

Go up one level in this thread


On November 27, 2002 at 17:56:31, Mike Byrne wrote:

>On November 27, 2002 at 16:42:03, James Constance wrote:
>
>>Where's the message that listed some of the shortcomings of the initial release?
>> The program seems pretty good to me.
>
>The recent upgrade fix some of the problems with analysis function
>
>The issues are:
>
>1. No Pgn support.  Without PGN support - there is no easy way to get your game
>onto your PC for more in-depth analysis.  A major shortcoming IMO.
>2. Does not remember the game position if you switch to another app and
>comeback.  I was told this would be fix in the next upgrade.  A major annoyance
>feature.
>3. Has an annoying nag screen to "save settings" when switching to another app.
>I was told this would be removed in the next upgrade. In additon, it will
>automatically remember settings.
>4.  The default personality has pondering on.  For a palm, I don't think this
>proper - because with pondering on and on battery - you will not get much more
>than 2 hour usage.  The default should be pondering off.  With pondering off,
>you can easily get 6 hours playing chess with your Palm.  Since it doesn't
>remember settings - you are always fidding with the commands and spending less
>time playing.
>5.  Re-read the last sentence in Point 4.  You spend a lot more time fidding
>with the controls in Chessmaster than in Tiger or Genius - are you buying it to
>play chess or you buying it to fiddle with the commands?  If it is the former
>Tiger and Genius win hands down.
>6.  I do get fatal error messages when in the tournament mode.  A fatal error
>message in tournament mode is FATAL tp your tournament.  You lose the whole
>tournament and your back to square one and fiddling with the commands again.
>NOT FUN!
>7.  Overall - a very frustrating program to play with is my assessment.
>Although it does have entertainmaint potential if they can make  it  run
>smoother, more stable and more user friendly.  It's not there yet.
>
>#1 Tiger
>#2 Genius
>
>
>Mike


Also, CM for Palm displays 2 tiny boards at the top of the screen on Sony Clie
320x320 models.  I.e., its display is totally screwed up on those popular
models.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.