Author: Kurt Utzinger
Date: 07:27:02 03/15/03
Go up one level in this thread
On March 15, 2003 at 10:11:14, Christophe Theron wrote: >On March 15, 2003 at 09:59:05, Kurt Utzinger wrote: > >>Comparison Fritz8 vs Shredder7 >>Vergleich zwischen Fritz8 gegen Shredder7 >>Comparaison entre Fritz8 et Shredder7 >>Engine/Engine-Match, Time control 40'/40+40'/40+40' >>Athlon 1.3/64 MB hash, ponder=off, 4-men TB's >>Books/Bücher/Livres d'ouverture [write protected/schreibgeschützt] >>******************************************************************* >> >>1) 100 x Fritz 8005 vs Shredder 7.00 [remis.ctg] result = 45,0-55,0 >>2) 100 x Fritz 8005 vs Shredder 7.04 [remis.ctg] >>3) 100 x Fritz 8005 vs Shredder 7.04 [f8-s7.ctg] result = 40,0-60,0 >>4) 100 x Fritz 8005 vs Shredder 7.00 [f8-s7.ctg] >>5) 100 x Fritz 80023 vs Shredder 7.00 [remis.ctg] >>6) 100 x Fritz 80023 vs Shredder 7.04 [remis.ctg] result = 40,5-59,5 >>7) 100 x Fritz 80023 vs Shredder 7.00 [f8-s7.ctg] >>8) 100 x Fritz 80023 vs Shredder 7.04 [f8-s7.ctg] >> >> >>In the meantime 3 series have been played but all three 100 games-matches were >>won by Shredder7. The results are - whichever versions we consider - rather >>similar. And as we can see from series 3) and 6) the books used have no >>influence at all. > > >So Sandro's work would not make a difference at all? > >Has Sandro's book been used in this match? I guess it has been (S7.ctg)? > > > > Christophe Yes, it was the Shredder7.ctg but some people argue that Sandro's book would only work properly under Shredder7-Classic-GUI [we played under Hiarcs8-GUI] or that the books for ChessBase-GUI and S7-Classic-GUI would be different. Kurt > > > > > > We do not think that there is significant difference between >>the various Fritz8 versions and maybe we stop the test. >> >>Entretemps 3 séries [à 100 parties] ont été jouées, mais trois fois Shredder7 >>était le vainceur. Il ne joue aucune role si on utilise le livret d'ouverture >>remis.ctg ou les fritz8.ctg et shredder7.ctg. Les différentes versions de Fritz >>sont très similaires. Nous considérons de stop les matches. >> >>Nun sind bereits 3 Serien gespielt. Und alle 3 Serien über je 100 Partien konnte >>Shredder7 für sich entscheiden. Unabhängig der eingesetzten Versionen sind die >>Resultate vergleichbar. Und den Bucheinfluss [remis.ctg oder eigenen Bücher] >>scheint es nicht zu geben. Wir überlegen uns deshalb, den Test zu beenden. >> >> >>Serie 1: Match Fritz 8005 vs Shredder 7</b> >> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. >> 1 Shredder 7 : 2617 65 52 100 55.0 % 2583 >> 2 Fritz 8005 : 2583 52 65 100 45.0 % 2617 >> >> >>Individual statistics: >> >>(1) Shredder 7 : 100 (+ 38,= 34,- 28), 55.0 % >> >>Fritz 8005 : 100 (+ 38,= 34,- 28), 55.0 % >> >> >>(2) Fritz 8005 : 100 (+ 28,= 34,- 38), 45.0 % >> >>Shredder 7 : 100 (+ 28,= 34,- 38), 45.0 % >> >>*************************************************************************** >> >><b>Serie 3: Match Fritz8005 vs Shredder 7.04</b> >><tt><pcode> >> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. >>Draws >> >> 1 Shredder 7.04 : 2635 61 58 100 60.0 % 2565 30.0 >>% >> 2 Fritz 8005 : 2565 58 61 100 40.0 % 2635 >>30.0% >></pcode></tt> >> >> >><tt><pcode>Individual statistics: >> >>(1) Shredder 7.04 : 100 (+ 45,= 30,- 25), 60.0 % >> >>Fritz 8005 : 100 (+ 45,= 30,- 25), 60.0 % >> >> >>(2) Fritz 8 : 100 (+ 25,= 30,- 45), 40.0 % >> >>Shredder 7.04 : 100 (+ 25,= 30,- 45), 40.0 %</pcode></tt> >> >>************************************************************************** >> >> >><b>Serie 6: Match Fritz 80023 vs Shredder 7.04</b> >> >><tt><pcode> >> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. >>Draws >> 1 Shredder 7.04 : 2633 61 56 100 59.5 % 2567 33.0 >>% >> 2 Fritz 80023 : 2567 56 61 100 40.5 % 2633 33.0 >>% >> >></pcode></tt> >> >><tt><pcode>Individual statistics: >> >>(1) Shredder 7.04 : 100 (+ 43,= 33,- 24), 59.5 % >> >>Fritz 80023 : 100 (+ 43,= 33,- 24), 59.5 % >> >> >>(2) Fritz 80023 : 100 (+ 24,= 33,- 43), 40.5 % >> >>Shredder 7.04 : 100 (+ 24,= 33,- 43), 40.5 %</pcode></tt> >> >> >>Homepage "Kurt & Rolf Chess": http://www.beepworld.de/members39/utzinger
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.