Author: Robert Hyatt
Date: 14:11:48 11/09/98
Go up one level in this thread
On November 09, 1998 at 15:47:31, odell hall wrote: > >On November 09, 1998 at 13:50:11, Bruce Moreland wrote: > >> >>On November 09, 1998 at 12:39:46, odell hall wrote: >> >>>You are exactly right! If the match did in fact happen why haven't they >>>published the games? The kasparov match is over so they can't fear that kasparov >>>will see the games. What other possible motivation for not revealing the games >>>other than that it never occured!! >> >>If this thread is going to start up again, please let it not go down this >>particular path. >> >>When you say that match never occurred, you are saying that a particular person, >>namely Murray Campbell, lied to me when I asked him about this match after a >>lecture. You are also saying that Feng Hsu lied to Bob in email between those >>two. >> > > > >I am not accusing anyone of lying, I was not aware that feng hu personally told >bob hyatt about the match results. Still the question has yet to be answered why >haven't the games been revealed? This is a very simple question, If such a match >between deepblue and the micro's did in fact occur it is a tremendously >important event and should be published! > Hsu told me about this privately. He and Murray both have discussed this at a couple of presentations they have given since the DB match. however I doubt they will say much here as it would only take a word by one of them to get the personal attacks going like crazy, by those that "hate big iron." > >>Whatever you think about IBM or Deep Blue or any of the rest of this, these guys >>don't deserve to be accused of lying. >> >>I think discussion of those games will be fruitless because we don't have them, >>and the details surrounding how they were played are still fuzzy. Any >>conclusions drawn from them are only minimally useful in my pesonal opinion. >> >>The only thing worse than making conclusions from these games is making >>conclusions out of thin air, which is the alternative. >> >>Fact is that the obvious questions about how DB would do against micros can't be >>answered. It is only possible to speculate. >> >>bruce
This page took 0.04 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.