Author: Jorge Pichard
Date: 10:21:31 10/22/03
Ruffian 1.0.5 is so strong that it can beat Comet B62.2 without using its
Opening Book, therefore, the 40 rating points advantage that the Opening Book
should give Comet doesn't even really matter at all. I will let this match
continue until it reaches 10 games, but so far I'm convinced that either Comet
Opening Book is too weak or Ruffian 1.0.5 is way too strong for Comet B62.2
[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2003.10.22"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Comet-wb"]
[Black "Ruffian_105"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C10"]
[Opening "French"]
[Time "12:49:16"]
[Variation "Rubinstein variation"]
[TimeControl "1800+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "168"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
1.e4 e6 {-0.23/13} 2.d4 d5 {-0.17/11} 3.Nc3 dxe4 {-0.21/11} 4.Nxe4 Nc6
{-0.24/11} 5.Nf3 {0.15/10} Be7 {-0.31/11} 6.Bc4 {0.21/10} Nf6 {-0.28/12} 7.Nxf6+
{0.55/11}
Bxf6 {-0.31/14} 8.c3 {0.44/11} O-O {-0.34/13} 9.O-O {0.42/10} e5 {-0.28/13}
10.dxe5
{0.68/10} Nxe5 {-0.37/13} 11.Nxe5 {0.50/11} Qxd1 {-0.34/14} 12.Rxd1 {0.72/12}
Bxe5
{-0.34/13} 13.Re1 {0.49/11} Bd6 {-0.35/13} 14.Bg5 {0.43/11} Bd7 {-0.33/13}
15.Be7
{0.40/11} Rfe8 {-0.34/14} 16.Bxd6 {0.29/11} cxd6 {-0.34/14} 17.Red1 {0.47/11}
Be6
{-0.35/14} 18.Bb5 {0.42/12} Red8 {-0.37/14} 19.Rd4 {0.43/12} a6 {-0.36/13}
20.Bd3
{0.51/11} Rd7 {-0.31/13} 21.f3 {0.48/10} g6 {-0.35/12} 22.a4 {0.56/11} d5
{-0.29/13}
23.Re1 {0.46/10} Kf8 {-0.29/12} 24.Bb1 {0.47/10} Re8 {-0.32/12} 25.Ba2 {0.58/11}
Rb8
{-0.38/12} 26.Re5 {0.67/10} Rbd8 {-0.39/14} 27.a5 {0.53/10} R7d6 {-0.30/13}
28.Re2
{0.51/10} f6 {-0.46/13} 29.Red2 {0.62/10} R6d7 {-0.53/13} 30.Bb3 {0.67/11} Ke7
{-0.52/12}
31.Kf2 {0.64/10} h6 {-0.54/11} 32.h4 {0.70/10} R7d6 {-0.49/11} 33.Bc2 {0.75/11}
f5
{-0.42/12} 34.h5 {0.65/10} g5 {-0.34/12} 35.Rb4 {0.57/10} R8d7 {-0.28/12} 36.g3
{0.49/10}
Kf6 {-0.14/12} 37.Ba4 {0.24/10} Rc7 {-0.13/12} 38.Kg2 {0.00/10} Bf7 {-0.11/12}
39.g4 {0.24/10} f4 {-0.08/12} 40.Kf2 {0.24/10} Be6 {-0.10/12} 41.Kg1 {0.18/9}
Ke5
{-0.06/12} 42.Bc2 {0.38/9} Rdc6 {-0.06/13} 43.Re2+ {0.27/10} Kf6 {-0.01/14}
44.Ba4
{0.14/10} Rd6 {0.00/14} 45.Be8 {0.06/10} Bc8 {0.06/13} 46.Bg6 {0.06/10} Re6
{0.05/13}
47.Rxe6+ {0.10/10} Bxe6 {0.00/17} 48.Rb6 {0.12/12} Ke5 {0.13/16} 49.Bd3
{0.10/11} d4
{0.05/15} 50.cxd4+ {1.95/10} Kxd4 {0.06/15} 51.Rxe6 {0.84/11} Kxd3 {0.08/15}
52.Rxh6
{0.24/12} Ke3 {0.72/16} 53.Kg2 {-0.31/12} Rc2+ {0.72/15} 54.Kh3 {-0.31/12} Kxf3
{0.72/15}
55.Rb6 {-0.39/12} Rg2 {1.04/16} 56.Rb3+ {-0.45/13} Kf2 {1.12/16} 57.Rc3
{-1.68/13}
Rg3+ {1.11/15} 58.Kh2 {-1.46/12} Rxg4 {1.16/15} 59.h6 {-1.46/12} f3 {1.21/15}
60.Rc2+ {-1.57/11} Ke3 {1.17/16} 61.Rc3+ {-1.57/10} Ke2 {1.27/16} 62.Rc2+
{-1.13/10}
Kd1 {1.37/16} 63.Rf2 {-0.96/10} Rh4+ {1.41/16} 64.Kg3 {-0.96/9} Rxh6 {1.41/15}
65.Rxf3 {-1.04/9} Kc2 {1.42/14} 66.Rf2+ {-1.21/9} Kb3 {1.62/15} 67.Kg4 {-1.26/9}
Rh4+
{2.04/15} 68.Kxg5 {-1.31/8} Rb4 {2.02/16} 69.Kf6 {-1.58/9} Rb5 {2.09/16} 70.Rf3+
{-2.42/9} Kb4 {2.10/16} 71.Ra3 {-1.72/9} Rxa5 {2.71/15} 72.Rg3 {-1.75/8} Ra2
{2.72/15}
73.Rg4+ {-1.75/8} Kb3 {2.81/15} 74.Rg3+ {-3.28/8} Kxb2 {2.98/16} 75.Rg4
{-4.52/8} b5
{3.73/14} 76.Ke5 {-4.29/8} a5 {3.95/13} 77.Kd5 {-4.93/8} b4 {4.08/13} 78.Kc4
{-5.48/8} b3
{5.41/14} 79.Rg2+ {-5.79/8} Ka3 {6.20/14} 80.Rg3 {-6.70/9} Rc2+ {9.10/13} 81.Kb5
{-6.81/9} Ka2 {9.75/14} 82.Kxa5 {-6.98/9} b2 {M29/10} 83.Rg4 {-7.80/8} Rc5+
{M28/1}
84.Ka6 {-15.58/8} {White resigns} 0-1
[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2003.10.22"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Ruffian_105"]
[Black "Comet-wb"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B53"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Time "13:52:15"]
[Variation "Chekhover, Zaitsev variation"]
[TimeControl "1800+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "99"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
1.e4 {0.01/13} c5 2.Nf3 {0.24/12} d6 3.d4 {0.24/11} cxd4 4.Qxd4 {0.31/11} Nc6
5.Qa4 {0.35/12} Bd7 {-0.39/10} 6.Nc3 {0.36/11} g6 {-0.38/10} 7.Qb3 {0.30/11} Bg7
{-0.37/10} 8.Bd3 {0.26/10} Qa5 {-0.36/9} 9.O-O {0.29/11} Bxc3 {-0.52/9} 10.bxc3
{0.49/12}
Nf6 {-0.46/9} 11.Bc4 {0.37/11} Nd8 {-0.57/10} 12.Re1 {0.42/12} Ba4 {-0.65/10}
13.Qa3 {0.47/12} Nc6 {-0.84/10} 14.Bb3 {0.45/11} Bxb3 {-0.80/11} 15.Qxa5
{0.47/14}
Nxa5 {-0.77/11} 16.axb3 {0.52/15} Nc6 {-0.80/11} 17.e5 {0.62/15} dxe5 {-0.72/11}
18.Nxe5 {0.70/14} Nxe5 {-0.81/11} 19.Rxe5 {0.70/13} Ng4 {-0.83/10} 20.Rb5
{1.38/13} a6
{-1.54/11} 21.Bf4 {1.44/14} Ra7 {-1.82/10} 22.f3 {1.80/14} Nf6 {-2.03/11} 23.Be3
{1.72/14}
O-O {-2.42/11} 24.Rb4 {2.05/14} a5 {-2.44/11} 25.Rb5 {2.09/14} Ra6 {-2.69/11}
26.Rxb7 {2.23/13} Rfa8 {-2.77/10} 27.c4 {2.45/12} e5 {-2.98/9} 28.Re7 {2.70/13}
a4
{-3.16/10} 29.Rxe5 {2.84/13} a3 {-3.39/9} 30.Ra2 {3.03/13} Rd6 {-3.50/10} 31.Kf2
{3.23/13}
Rd1 {-3.89/9} 32.Re7 {3.68/12} Rh1 {-4.06/10} 33.Bc5 {3.90/13} Rxh2 {-4.09/10}
34.Rxa3 {4.03/13} Rd8 {-4.06/10} 35.Ra6 {3.96/12} Nh5 {-4.33/9} 36.Bb4 {3.97/12}
Rh1
{-3.95/9} 37.Be1 {4.01/13} Rb8 {-3.83/9} 38.Raa7 {4.26/13} Rf8 {-4.05/10} 39.b4
{4.15/13}
Ng7 {-3.75/9} 40.c5 {4.27/12} Nf5 {-4.02/8} 41.Re4 {4.08/12} h5 {-4.02/8} 42.b5
{4.10/12} h4 {-3.94/9} 43.c6 {4.22/11} Rc8 {-3.99/8} 44.c7 {5.08/11} Ng3
{-4.41/9}
45.Rxh4 {6.00/12} Rxh4 {-5.38/9} 46.Kxg3 {7.40/13} Rh5 {-7.13/10} 47.b6
{7.40/12} Rg5+
{-6.29/10} 48.Kf2 {7.42/13} Rc5 {-8.12/10} 49.Ba5 {8.67/13} Rxc2+ {-10.25/10}
{Black
resigns} 1-0
[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2003.10.22"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Comet-wb"]
[Black "Ruffian_105"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C10"]
[Opening "French"]
[Time "14:47:48"]
[Variation "Frere (Becker) variation"]
[TimeControl "1800+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "182"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
1.e4 e6 {-0.23/13} 2.d4 d5 {-0.17/11} 3.Nc3 dxe4 {-0.21/11} 4.Nxe4 Qd5
{-0.19/10} 5.Nc3 Bb4 {-0.22/12} 6.Nf3 Nf6 {-0.26/11} 7.Bd3 Ne4 {-0.21/12} 8.Bd2
Bxc3
{-0.28/13} 9.bxc3 Nxd2 {-0.32/13} 10.Qxd2 c5 {-0.30/12} 11.c4 {0.69/10} Qd8
{-0.38/13}
12.dxc5 {0.55/10} Qc7 {-0.11/10} 13.Qg5 {0.86/10} O-O {-0.13/11} 14.O-O {0.62/9}
Na6
{-0.15/12} 15.c6 {0.93/10} bxc6 {-0.23/12} 16.Rab1 {1.01/10} Rb8 {-0.18/12}
17.Rxb8
{1.11/10} Nxb8 {-0.19/13} 18.Qh4 {0.91/10} g6 {-0.16/12} 19.Rb1 {0.98/10} f6
{-0.07/11}
20.Qh6 {0.62/9} Na6 {0.05/11} 21.Nd2 {0.56/9} e5 {0.00/11} 22.Qe3 {0.44/9} Rd8
{0.09/11} 23.f3 {0.26/9} Qe7 {0.16/11} 24.Ne4 {0.25/10} Bf5 {0.11/12} 25.c3
{0.15/10} Rd7
{0.19/11} 26.Re1 {-0.11/10} Bxe4 {0.22/12} 27.Bxe4 {-0.17/11} Qd6 {0.20/13}
28.Rb1
{-0.21/11} Kg7 {0.33/12} 29.Ra1 {-0.40/10} f5 {0.78/14} 30.Bc2 {-0.50/11} Qc5
{0.64/13}
31.Qxc5 {-0.59/12} Nxc5 {0.77/13} 32.Re1 {-0.59/12} Kf6 {0.83/14} 33.Kf1
{-0.92/11} Rb7
{0.84/14} 34.Rd1 {-1.00/11} Rb6 {0.81/13} 35.a4 {-0.83/10} e4 {0.84/12} 36.fxe4
{-0.98/11} fxe4 {0.96/13} 37.Re1 {-0.93/11} Ke5 {0.97/14} 38.Re2 {-0.92/11} Rb2
{0.91/13}
39.Ke1 {-0.94/11} Ra2 {0.95/13} 40.g3 {-0.95/10} g5 {1.04/13} 41.Kd2 {-0.94/11}
g4
{1.05/14} 42.Re3 {-0.97/11} Nb3+ {1.05/15} 43.Kd1 {-0.97/12} Ra1+ {1.12/16}
44.Ke2
{-1.01/12} Nc5 {1.12/16} 45.Kd2 {-1.01/12} Rh1 {1.06/16} 46.Re2 {-1.01/12} Rf1
{1.10/15}
47.Re1 {-1.02/11} Rf2+ {1.09/14} 48.Re2 {-1.03/11} Rf7 {1.10/14} 49.Re3
{-1.03/12}
Rd7+ {1.08/14} 50.Ke2 {-1.03/12} Rd6 {1.08/16} 51.Ke1 {-1.03/12} a5 {1.08/16}
52.Kf1
{-1.06/11} Rd2 {1.01/15} 53.Re2 {-0.81/11} Rd7 {1.04/15} 54.Re3 {-1.03/11} Rf7+
{1.10/16}
55.Ke1 {-1.03/12} Rf3 {1.02/16} 56.Ke2 {-1.03/11} Rf5 {1.05/14} 57.Kd2
{-1.03/11} Rf2+
{1.05/15} 58.Re2 {-1.03/11} Rf6 {1.03/15} 59.Re3 {-1.03/11} h6 {1.03/15} 60.Ke2
{-1.02/11} Rf3 {1.03/15} 61.Kd2 {-1.02/11} Rf8 {1.00/15} 62.Re2 {-1.02/11} Rf7
{0.98/15}
63.h3 {-1.00/10} Rf3 {1.02/14} 64.hxg4 {-1.04/10} Rxg3 {1.27/14} 65.Rh2
{-0.99/9} Nd3
{1.09/13} 66.Bxd3 {-0.90/9} Rxd3+ {1.18/13} 67.Ke2 {-1.40/10} Rxc3 {1.21/15}
68.Rxh6
{-1.14/10} Rxc4 {1.13/15} 69.Rh5+ {-1.03/9} Kd4 {1.17/15} 70.Rxa5 {-1.13/8} Rc2+
{1.10/14}
71.Kf1 {-1.25/8} Rc1+ {1.07/14} 72.Ke2 {-1.30/9} Rg1 {1.08/14} 73.Rg5 {-1.17/9}
Rg2+
{1.30/12} 74.Kf1 {-1.42/9} Ra2 {1.31/14} 75.Ra5 {-2.06/9} c5 {1.71/14} 76.g5
{-2.48/8}
Ra1+ {1.65/13} 77.Kg2 {-2.48/8} e3 {2.47/14} 78.Kf3 {-2.29/9} Kd3 {2.26/15}
79.Rxc5
{-1.82/9} e2 {2.14/14} 80.Rd5+ {-1.97/9} Kc4 {3.29/15} 81.Re5 {-2.00/9} e1=Q
{3.46/14}
82.Re4+ {-2.81/8} Kd5 {M22/13} 83.Rxe1 {-2.82/9} Rxe1 {M21/2} 84.a5 {-2.91/8}
Ra1
{M20/7} 85.Kg4 {-2.95/8} Rxa5 {M18/1} 86.Kf5 {-2.77/9} Ra2 {M17/1} 87.Kf6
{-2.83/9} Kd6
{M16/1} 88.g6 {-2.01/10} Rf2+ {M13/1} 89.Kg7 {-8.95/10} Ke7 {M11/1} 90.Kh6
{-10.30/11}
Rg2 {M9/1} 91.Kh5 {-10.38/12} {White resigns} 0-1
[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2003.10.22"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Ruffian_105"]
[Black "Comet-wb"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "C47/05"]
[Opening "Four knights"]
[Time "15:51:49"]
[Variation "Scotch (4...exd4 5.Nxd4)"]
[TimeControl "1800+2"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "83"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]
1.e4 {0.01/13} e5 2.Nf3 {0.05/12} Nc6 3.Nc3 {0.09/12} Nf6 4.d4 {0.08/12} exd4
5.Nxd4 {0.05/12} Bb4 6.Nxc6 {-0.05/12} bxc6 7.Bd3 {-0.03/12} d5 8.exd5 {0.02/11}
cxd5
9.O-O {0.05/11} O-O 10.Bg5 {0.00/11} c6 11.Re1 {0.01/10} Be6 {-0.24/10} 12.Qf3
{0.05/10} Re8 {-0.14/10} 13.Bxf6 {0.09/11} Qxf6 {0.25/11} 14.Qxf6 {0.06/13} gxf6
{0.16/10} 15.a3 {0.08/13} Bd6 {0.31/11} 16.Ne2 {0.02/13} c5 {0.27/11} 17.Rad1
{0.06/12}
Rab8 {0.36/11} 18.b3 {-0.09/14} Red8 {0.41/11} 19.a4 {-0.09/14} Bc7 {0.30/11}
20.Bb5
{0.00/13} Bf5 {0.12/10} 21.Rdc1 {0.00/12} Bg6 {0.28/10} 22.Kf1 {0.00/12} Rb6
{0.63/10}
23.Bd3 {-0.06/12} Re6 {0.60/10} 24.Ng3 {-0.13/12} Rde8 {0.56/10} 25.Rcb1
{-0.17/11} a5
{0.70/10} 26.Rbd1 {-0.09/12} Bxg3 {0.63/11} 27.hxg3 {0.00/13} Bxd3+ {0.55/11}
28.cxd3
{-0.02/14} f5 {0.56/12} 29.d4 {-0.07/16} cxd4 {0.72/13} 30.Rdb1 {-0.30/16}
R6xe1+
{0.99/12} 31.Rxe1 {-1.15/3} Rxe1+ {0.38/13} 32.Kxe1 {-1.15/3} Kf8 {-1.46/15}
33.b4
{2.53/15} Ke7 {-2.70/15} 34.bxa5 {3.13/15} Kd6 {-2.88/15} 35.Kd2 {3.31/15} h6
{-2.99/14}
36.Kd3 {4.18/18} Kc5 {-4.84/15} 37.a6 {4.76/17} Kb6 {-5.70/15} 38.Kxd4 {5.10/18}
Kc6
{-5.70/13} 39.a7 {6.34/16} Kb7 {-9.88/14} 40.Kxd5 {7.77/17} Ka8 {-14.42/14}
41.Ke5
{10.10/18} Kxa7 {-15.86/15} {Black resigns} 1-0
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.