Author: stuart taylor
Date: 18:35:02 11/19/03
Go up one level in this thread
On November 19, 2003 at 20:53:15, Rex wrote: >On November 19, 2003 at 16:58:01, Daniel Clausen wrote: > >>Most of us here in CCC agree that in order to find out whether X or Y is stonger >>takes _a lot_ of games, especially when their strength is close to each other. >> >>It's amazing what people think about results of 2.5-1.5, 2-2 or 1.5-2.5, when it >>comes to human-comps though... >> >>And... >> >>It's not: >>-GK doesn't fight for human kind when fighting Fritz >>-GK doesn't save the human race when he beats the machine 2.5-1.5 >>-it's not a victory of the machines when Fritz wins 2.5-1.5 >>-chess is not rendered useless if Fritz wins >>-etc >> >>it is: >>-it's simply a commercial event with money and product placement at stake >>-fun to watch >>-only bearable in ICC with 'set kib 2' >>-etc >> >>GK will play computers in such events as long as there's a sponsor. He doesn't >>"deserve another chance" or anything like that. >> >>Sargon > > >I get so tired of this crap. And this goes with comp ver comp games. If two >parties agree on FOUR games and there is a winner then we can say the winner >is_the_best_or even the strongest. If this was NOT to be the case then we can >say the same about any Super Bowl winner. OH it was only one game. What? you >expect to play 100 super bowl games. > >Look a tourney is an agreed tourney between two parties with the understanding >of possibly ONE winner who has the GLORY of saying I AM THE BEST!! Dont take >anything away from a winner. In the Kaspy ver Computer match we can say there >were no winners. Title wise. And how bout 1000 boxing matches? Anyway, when there is a draw, it DOESN'T make anyone prove stronger, and when one wins by half a point, it doesn't make him look like the weaker player. Putting Kasparovs last 3 man/machine matches togeher, also, doesn't make Kasparov look better than the machine either! (even if he is full of determination at revenge). S.Taylor
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.