Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: do all programs see this draw here.... another position

Author: Robert Hyatt

Date: 07:46:11 12/28/03

Go up one level in this thread


On December 28, 2003 at 04:46:07, martin fierz wrote:

>On December 27, 2003 at 00:51:11, Mike Byrne wrote:
>
>>
>>[d]8/r7/8/5bk1/8/5B2/5RPP/6K1 b - - 0 1
>
>for all programs that instantly saw the draw in mike's
>position, this may be interesting too (of course only
>without tablebases): white to move and win, a study by
>J. Vancura 1922, which is also on the chessbase site.
>
>[d]8/8/8/8/8/2K4B/5k1P/8 w - - 0 1
>
>the point is that although black's king is in the
>square of the white pawn, he can never get through
>to the h-file. programs which are too speculative about
>"wrong bishop => draw" might show a draw score before
>they see the win.
>
>cheers
>  martin


Mine _never_ says draw in this position:

              depth   time  score   variation (1)
                1     0.00   4.05   1. Bf5
                1->   0.02   4.05   1. Bf5
                2     0.02   3.82   1. Bf5 Ke3
                2->   0.02   3.82   1. Bf5 Ke3
                3     0.02   4.12   1. Bf5 Ke3 2. h4
                3->   0.02   4.12   1. Bf5 Ke3 2. h4
                4     0.02   4.12   1. Bf5 Ke3 2. h4 Kf4
                4->   0.03   4.12   1. Bf5 Ke3 2. h4 Kf4
                5     0.03   4.12   1. Bf5 Ke3 2. h4 Kf4 3. Be6
                5     0.03   4.24   1. Bd7 Kf3 2. h4 Kf4 3. h5
                5     0.03   4.39   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Kf4 3. h5
                5->   0.03   4.39   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Kf4 3. h5
                6     0.03   4.39   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5
                6->   0.07   4.39   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5
                7     0.07     ++   1. Be6!!
                7     0.09   5.16   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                7->   0.13   5.16   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                8     0.15   5.26   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6
                8->   0.23   5.26   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6
                9     0.27   5.46   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Kd4
                9->   0.42   5.46   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Kd4
               10     0.48   5.56   1. Be6 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Bf5 Kf7
               10     0.65     ++   1. Bd7!!
               10     0.67  10.46   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke5
               10->   0.70  10.46   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke5
               11     0.84  10.21   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke7 6. h7 Kxe8 7. h8=Q+
               11->   1.18  10.21   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke7 6. h7 Kxe8 7. h8=Q+
               12     1.36  10.21   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke7 6. h7 Kxe8 7. h8=Q+
                                    Kd7
               12->   1.84  10.21   1. Bd7 Ke3 2. h4 Ke4 3. h5 Ke5 4. h6
                                    Kf6 5. Be8 Ke7 6. h7 Kxe8 7. h8=Q+
                                    Kd7


Etc (with no endgame tables, othnerwise it is instant mate of course):

              clearing hash tables
              time surplus   0.00  time limit 1666:39 (1666:39)
              depth   time  score   variation (1)
                1     0.00   3.92   1. Bd7
                1->   0.00   3.92   1. Bd7
                2     0.00     ++   1. Bd7!!
                2     0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>
                2->   0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>
                3     0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>
                3->   0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>
                4     0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>
                4->   0.00  Mat14   1. Bd7 <EGTB>


Of course in the first position it finds a draw instantly, whether it be
with egtbs or without...



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.