Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: I disagree

Author: Mike Byrne

Date: 10:59:55 12/29/03

Go up one level in this thread


On December 29, 2003 at 13:23:33, Sandro Necchi wrote:

>On December 29, 2003 at 12:46:47, Luis Smith wrote:
>
>>>I do agree too.
>>>
>>>Crafty has no realistic chances to win a WCCC.
>>>
>>>Sandro
>>
>>IMO only Bob can know this for sure.  I think people either over estimate the
>>commercials, or underestimate Crafty.  After all at the WCCC's only 11 games
>>were played, who knows what could have happened in that time, especially with
>>the kind of hardware that Dr. Hyatt could get.
>
>No, Bob does not know this.
>He is a "little outdated" on this matter.
>
>At the 2003 WCCC there were 3 favorites (Shredder, Fritz and Junior), 2 possible
>outsiders (Brutus and Diep).
>
>Based on my experience I gave these chances, before the tournament started:
>
>Shredder 35% (because of the slower hardware)
>Fritz    30%
>Junior   25%
>Brutus    7%
>Diep      3%
>rest      0%


The rest of the field is never 0%.  Any bookie can tell you that.  It might be
15 to 1, 30 to 1 -- even a 100 to 1 . but the chances are never "zero" - that
would make the payoff infinity.

Besides, the tournamnament format , imo, is stupid.  An 11 round swiss with 14
or so participants? - they should make a "normal" swiss (say 5 rounds with 14
participants or a round robin - add just 2 more rounds with 14 participants.  I
forget exactly the number of rounds and participants, but I'm not far off.


>
>Do you really believe Crafty is better than the average rest? I do not. He would
>have to rely on too many bugs on the competition. This is not realistic.
>
>Of course everybody can say anything different, but in reality this is the
>situation.
>
>Someone said that the WCCC is more or less a lottery.
>OK, than can someone can explaing why since 1996 only Junior and Shredder won?
>
>Sandro



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.