Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: What constitutes a winning position?

Author: Johanes Suhardjo

Date: 14:04:14 01/01/04

Go up one level in this thread


On December 27, 2003 at 23:15:58, Bob Durrett wrote:
>You may wish to examine "Understanding the Sacrifice: sacrifice your way to
>success" by Angus Dunnington, Copyright 2002, ISBN 1857443128.
>
>The underlying idea expressed in that book, which is about positional
>sacrifices, is that the top GMs are able to recognize positional factors which
>have value equal to or exceeding a certain amount of material.  For chess engine
>programmers, this translates into the following:  The ideal position evaluation
>code in a chess engine would be able to evaluate positions in such a way as to
>recognize and quantify positional factors. As an example, the code should be
>able to determine whether or not material should be given up for some other
>[positional] advantage or visa versa.  The searching should be such that moves
>[from an internal node] offering material for other advantages [or visa versa]
>would be identified and pursued.

Thanks for the info!


>What this means is that evaluation of games/lines based on material alone may
>not give you the information you want, at least not directly.

Agreed.  But the fens I collected might still be useful.  I may use them later.


>"Realization of a material advantage" is a recurring theme in the chess
>literature.  Sometimes it's "just matter of technique" and sometimes it takes
>brilliance.  The same could be said for "Realization of XXX" where XXX is some
>sort of positional advantage.  Incidentally, I see no reason why chess engines
>should not be able to play positional chess, including playing positional
>sacrifices.  A positional sacrifice is MERELY a conversion of one type of
>advantage to another.
>
>Bob D.

                                                 Johanes Suhardjo



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.