Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: The "Correct Assessment" of a Chess Position

Author: Bob Durrett

Date: 19:50:45 01/11/04

Go up one level in this thread


On January 11, 2004 at 17:08:56, George Sobala wrote:

>On January 11, 2004 at 15:33:09, Bob Durrett wrote:
>
>
>>
>>[Event "Karlsbad"]
>>[Site "Karlsbad"]
>>[Date "1923.??.??"]
>>[Round "?"]
>>[White "153 Alekhine, Alexander"]
>>[Black "Maroczy, Geza"]
>>[Result "1-0"]
>>[ECO "D55"]
>>[SetUp "1"]
>>[FEN "r1b3k1/pp1nq2p/8/3p2p1/3pP3/2QB4/PP1N2PP/5RK1 w - - 0 19"]
>>[PlyCount "7"]
>>[EventDate "1923.04.??"]
>>[Source "ChessBase"]
>>
>>19. Qc7 $1 {Alekhine:  "Immediately paralysing all the opponent's pieces;
>>Black's position becomes hopeless"} (19. Qxd4 $2 Qc5) 19... Kg7 20. Rf5 $1 dxe4
>>21. Nxe4 Qb4 (21... h6 22. h3 {Gufeld: "to be followed by Kg1-h2 and Ne4-d6"})
>>22. Rxg5+ {Black resigned} 1-0
>>
>>Alekhine's comment after White's 19th move is typical.  He was concerned about a
>>positional issue and not at all concerned about the sacrificed pawn.
>>
>>
>>[D] r1b3k1/pp1nq2p/8/3p2p1/3pP3/2QB4/PP1N2PP/5RK1 w
>>
>>Bob D.
>
>If it is of any interest, all the engines I've tried have chosen Qc7 within 1-2
>seconds of analysis, often less!
>
>Bob - any good chess engine will pay attention to multiple positional features
>when making its evaluation of a position. But ultimately the only "correct
>assessment" of a position is how it plays out. No matter how ugly it looks, if
>there is a winning line, that is enough.
>
>Features such as pawn structure, "good" v "bad" bishops, doubled pawns etc etc
>are only shorthand tricks for guessing the true value of a position without
>bothering to calculate things out. Indeed, they are often merely shorthand
>tricks for guessing whether, all other things being equal, the ending will be
>won or lost.
>
>Along these lines, read Watson's "Secrets of Modern Chess Strategy" next. A
>brilliant book. Highly recommended.

Thanks, George.

I did start reading that book awhile back but didn't finish it because of one
reason or another which I cannot recall.  I do have it on my list to STUDY soon,
perhaps after several others by higher rated players:

Alburt & Palatnik	Chess Strategy for the Tournament Player
AuIt	The Genesis of Power Chess: Effective Winning Techniques for Strategy and
Tactics
Barden	How Good is Your Chess? Rate your skill and improve your strategy by
participating in 35 master games
Beliavsky	Winning Endgame Strategy
Botvinnik	Michail Botvinnik: Master of Strategy Botvinnik's Best Games 1947-1970
  (4th Ed.)
Chernev	The Most Instructive Games of Chess Ever Played: 62 Masterpieces of
Chess Strategy
Dunnington	101 Winning Chess Strategies
Dvoretsky	Strategic Play:  School of Chess Excellence 3
Eingorn	Decision-Making at the Chessboard
Euwe	Strategy and Tactics in Chess
Gufeld & Kalienchenko	Chess Strategy
Jansa	Dynamics of chess strategy
Lasker	Modern Chess Strategy
Leininger	Middlegame Strategy with the Carlsbad Pawn Structure
Lisitsyn & Cafferty	Second Book of Chess Strategy
Mednis	Advanced Endgame Strategies
Pachman	Modern Chess Strategy
Pandolfini	Weapons of Chess: An Omnibus of Chess Strategy
Pickett	Enterprizing Strategy in the King's Indian Defense
Romero	Creative Chess Strategy
Schiller	Strategy for Advanced Players
Seirawan & Silman	Winning Chess Strategies
Shereshevsky	Endgame Strategy
Silman	The Complete Book of Chess Strategy Grandmaster Techniques from A to Z
Suba	Dynamic Chess Strategy
Unger	Strategical Themes
van Reek	Basic Strategy in the Endgame
van Reek	Hypermodern Strategy
Waitzkin	Josh Waitzkin's Attacking Chess: Aggressive Strategies and Inside Moves
Walker	Attacking the King: Fighting Strategy and Tactics for Checkmate
Watson	Secrets of Modern Chess Strategy: Advances Since Nimzowitsch

Bob D.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.