Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Go programming

Author: Dr. Oliver Brausch

Date: 05:26:57 02/13/04

Go up one level in this thread


On February 12, 2004 at 15:21:58, Dann Corbit wrote:

>>Some people say that no Go program will be stronger than the best humans for at
>>least another century, if ever!  Today's best Go programs are far weaker than
>>any Go professional.
>
>Hogwash.  Computers will have more compute power than the human brain long
>before a century passes.
>

I am not so sure about this, Dann. I have not played Go a lot, but it is
really a very stratetical game. Chess is both stratetical and tactical, which
is the fascinating point of chess. Computers are strong at tactics but still
very, very weak at stratetics.

And what will be in 100 years? Computer 10^6 times faster than now, even
perhaps 10^9??? yes, but it will be a finite number. So we got some plies deeper
on Go, some more plies on chess.

But the human brain with stratetic power thinks even much deeper than that
will be. They have a feeling for the position, for the pattern, what computers
are missing. Perhaps some day there will be Artificial Integences with
that skill, but I am not sure if they can be called Computers then.

Intersting point to that:
It was almost 10 years ago, when the best Chess computers started
to beat GMs. So all people predicted that in 10 years computers will
be unbeatable by human. And what is now? Computers 100 times faster still
are beaten by humans.
And I predict something: In 10 years they still will be beaten by
humans! (not by me, btw...)
I think there is a bifurcation: Or you solve a game (like checkers), then
the computer is unbeatable or the computer will never be unbeatable.

Dr. Oliver Brausch



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.