Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: To use or not to use Hungarian Notation, this is the question (o.t)

Author: José Carlos

Date: 09:44:26 03/05/04

Go up one level in this thread


On March 05, 2004 at 12:04:56, Russell Reagan wrote:

>On March 05, 2004 at 03:39:02, José Carlos wrote:
>
>>  Attacked = ((UINT64)File[n] << 16) & WhiteAll
>>or instead of that:
>>  u64Attacked = ((UINT64)u8File[n] << 16) & u64WhiteAll
>>
>>  When next year I come back to this line to make some change, I hope to find
>>second verion rather than first.
>
>What if you move to a new 64-bit machine with lots of cache where accessing
>individual bytes is significantly slower than accessing larger data (16-bit,
>32-bit, or 64-bit)? Now you've got a lot of changes to make.
>
>With just about any modern IDE you can find out the type by placing the mouse
>cursor over the variable. If you're using vi and gcc, well, you've got me there
>:)


  It's of course a matter of taste in the end. When I watch the screen, like 40
lines of code, having the types in the prefixes make it clearer to me.


>In your code I would still prefer to hide the bit twiddling to make it more
>readable and abstract the HN away into the details. Maybe something like:
>
>Attacked = KnightAttacks(Square);


  Yes, of course. The example was just to show my point. The idea is when I read
that line (some time in the future), be it in a small function or anywhere else,
I find it usefull to immediately see I have a 8 bits thing being masked to a 64
bits thing.

  José C.



>If you want to use HN within the KnightAttacks function, that would seem more
>reasonable to me. Instead of worrying about what type everything is all over
>your program, you just have to worry about what type the things are within small
>little functions like that. They can be inlined of course, and with C++ they
>will be typesafe so your compiler will yell at you if your types get messed up.
>
>But I guess this is still a personal preference. I like my code to be more
>abstracted because I like to fiddle with it and change lots of things to see
>what works better.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.