Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: What is a good eval worth? (Some surprising results)

Author: James Swafford

Date: 18:19:45 03/17/04


Just what is a good eval worth?

I ran Crafty on an AMD XP 2000+ (about 1.5 ghz) on ICC with a stripped
down eval, then with it's regular eval to find out.  Check out the
summaries below (the top one is for stripped eval, of course).

By "stripped down", I mean that the eval counted only material, some
very crude pawn heuristics (doubled pawn, passed pawn, isolated
pawn), and used pawn and knight piece square tables.  That's it.

I'm a bit surprised that the difference isn't a bit more; it's
less than 200 points for blitz and bullet.  I strongly suspect
the difference would've been much greater for standard games,
but I have no data to support that.

Anyone done similar tests?


 cnt |          avg          |          avg          | base_secs | inc_secs |
description
-----+-----------------------+-----------------------+-----------+----------+-------------
 271 | 2313.6531365313653137 | 1731.1623616236162362 |       120 |        1 | Br
   2 | 2431.0000000000000000 | 1031.0000000000000000 |       300 |        3 | bu
 673 | 2409.4680534918276374 | 1654.3239227340267459 |       300 |        3 | br
(3 rows)

 cnt |          avg          |          avg          | base_secs | inc_secs |
description
-----+-----------------------+-----------------------+-----------+----------+-------------
 246 | 2476.1422764227642276 | 1644.9471544715447154 |       120 |        1 | Br
   2 | 2436.0000000000000000 | 1845.0000000000000000 |       120 |        1 | Bu
 567 | 2583.1869488536155203 | 1653.4673721340388007 |       300 |        3 | br


--
James




This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.