Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Two questions: Bratko Kopec and variations on the killer heuristic

Author: Artem Pyatakov

Date: 00:55:18 03/30/04


Hello again,

Thanks to everyone who has been active in my previous thread - all of these
responses have been helpful and show the diversity of opinion that will
definitely be discussed in my thesis.

As I attempt to run some experiments for my thesis work, I have run into these
two questions:

1) Do you think the Bratko-Kopec test suite is at all a reasonable test? Or is
this known to have a lot of problems? Is it outdated? I've been running
experiment on ECM and WAC, but a lot of the previous chess research uses
Bratko-Kopec, so I am thinking of perhaps rerunning my experiments with that
testsuite.

2) A completely unrelated (to my research) idea has occured to me, as I was
documenting various parts of a standard chess program in the paper. Have people
tried messing around a lot with the Killer Heuristic that everyone finds so
helpful? Do any of you use anything else besides the "2 killers" approach in
Crafty? A very, very quick experiment with about 5 positions showed a measurable
decrease in node counts if I for instance also checked the Killers from two and
four plies lower and from two plies higher. What have people tried in this area?
What about 3 or 4 killers?

Thanks in advance!

Artem



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.