Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Shredder 8 disadvantaged in future SSDF lists?(not only shredder)

Author: Sandro Necchi

Date: 04:50:09 05/12/04

Go up one level in this thread


On May 12, 2004 at 07:42:31, Uri Blass wrote:

>On May 12, 2004 at 07:18:50, Mike Hood wrote:
>
>>The way to get maximum playing strength out of Shredder 8 is to use the UCI
>>engine in Shredder's Classic GUI with Sandro Necchi's new opening book, the book
>>mode set to "Tournament" in the GUI.
>>
>>But the SSDF will never test Shredder 8 in this configuration, because it's a
>>combination of two separately marketed products. The Shredder 8 UCI engine is
>>sold by Chessbase, and the GUI is sold at www.shredderchess.de.

Hi Uri,

>
>It is also possible that the best way to get maximum strength of chessmaster is
>to use Fritz8.ctg under chessbase

It is not the same. I am the book maker for Shredder both for CB and UCI gui.

>
>If you allow combination of 2 products then you need to allow it for every
>engine.
>
>I am not against it.


Again cannot put this on the same level.

>I think that every engine should be tested in the way that the programmer likes
>and it includes the opening book that he likes and the interface that he choose.

So we did. We asked to test the UCI version with Shredder 8 book, but since it
is sold in two different packages it was not done.

I told the SSDF that the real update to the 7.04 UCI was the 8.0 UCI and that I
was not sure Shredder 8 CB would have topped the SSDF list. Looking the result I
was not that far away from reality...

>
>Of course credit for the right people should be given in notes to the list and
>the list can have different color for the programs that were tested as
>combination of more than one program.

It is the same program, only the book has an option for a more restricted
selection...how can you call this a combination of two different programs?

>
>Uri

Sandro



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.