Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Second Thoughts respect CM 10º edition

Author: Alain Lyrette

Date: 03:02:14 06/26/04

Go up one level in this thread



On June 25, 2004 at 15:54:13, Fernando Villegas wrote:

>After some extra testing and looking at CM 10.000, much or perhaps all the first
>somewhat childish enthusiasm I had for it has evaporated.
>Not that this product is deficient at all, but once you have begun to use it for
>real after the first enthralling feeling that invade a freak with just the idea
>you have in your hands something new, you rapidly comes to terms with a very
>simple reality: it is the fact this CM is "new" only with respect to the most
>shallow features. In every real aspect with CM 10º edition you have 99% of the
>very same product capable of beating you 100% of times, the same toy with lot of
>frills not  better than the older and sometimes even worse, the same fastidious
>Waitzkin with his same and so peculiar way not to talk english but to spurt an
>uninteligible new yorkian jargon, the same or a very similar engine, -perhaps
>stronger but that is moot to all of us-, etc.
>Then, for what?
>As John Merlino knows well because I corresponded with him about this two times
>or so  during his previous incarnation as Ubisoft employee, what I would
>consider "new" is a far cry of all CM 10 offer. I do no care about stronger
>engines as much, at least in this issue, I am reasonable enough not to ask for
>more, being already absolutely surpasssed by current state of the art. What I
>have been asking -Ed Schroeder also received from me, years ago, a petition of
>the sort- is something altogether different and superuior -I believe- in terms
>of utility for players of avrage force like me, that is to say, for people
>playing between 1800 and 2100 Elo.  There is nothing for this class of players
>in stock. Yes, Fritz offers some interesting features, even CM does so, but not
>to the degree neccesary.
>Or it could be I ama sking for an impossible thing.
>Anyway, CM 10 edition does not stand anymore in my purchasing list. Cm9000 is
>more tha enough, as it was cm80000, 7000, 6000, 5500 and 5000.
>
>Better to purchase more books...
>
>Fernando
Both Khalifman and Kasparov can beat me easily but i would rather lose against
Kasparov...knowwhatimean?!



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.