Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: About Off Topic Post and Moderators philosophy

Author: Harald Faber

Date: 07:00:03 12/23/98

Go up one level in this thread


On December 23, 1998 at 09:44:59, Fernando Villegas wrote:

>Hi candidates:
>I have read carefully your statements and  I feel very comfortable with the view
>of Larry T. and someone else, but I am afraid that althought all of you are
>mainly in a correct posture, with more or less inclination to be tough, I see
>with some worry a somewhat narrow criteria about off-posting activities. Let me
>say this very simple fact: off-post as any "off" comunication in any group is so
>esential to the life of the group as the the main stuff. Specially here: THIS IS
>NOT an specialized magazine in chess programming, where all the stuff should be
>about it; this is a newsgroup formed and runned by people. Of course all of us
>are interested in chess computers, BUT I dare to believe that the esential
>purpose of all of us to be here, even if we do not realize it, is to communicate
>with other fellows with the pretext of chess computers more than chess computer
>as such. At least so it is for those of us that are not chess programmers and so
>are not looking here just for some information. So, for the rest of us, no
>programmers guys, any communication going beyond the field that define the group
>cannot be considered as a kind of fault that can be "tolerated" or punished
>according the views of the moderator, but as something positive, something that
>give extra richness to and an extra reason to be here. Why I shouldn't be
>capable of talking about jazz with KK if the topic appears, and do it so post
>after post without "warnings" that we are off topic? Maybe somebody could say:
>"go to a jazz newsgroup", but then if I do so I will not meet there KK and
>besides it is precisely the mixture of other things with THIS thing that makes
>interesting such probable communication. Could you grasp that? Off topic civily
>conducted not only should be tolerated, but even stimulated. Anyway chess
>computer will stay being the main concern, no problems with that, but at the
>same time we will know more about each others and get more from our
>communication. Only insults and attacks should be catalogued as off topic.
>fernando

I would tolerate off-topic but in a limited way. No endless thread about beer.
That has to go into e-mail.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.