Author: Ricardo Gibert
Date: 13:14:12 07/09/04
Go up one level in this thread
On July 09, 2004 at 14:24:52, Wayne Lowrance wrote: >in a OTB move with my neighbor I put my hand over a piece to move, I had not >touched it but I had second thoughts, in removing my hand I accidently touched >the piece. We had a big beef over this. Should I have been forced to make the >move.....Thank You >Wayne >P>S> we play touch move I believe the FIDE rule is if it is——clear——that touching the piece was unintentional, then you don't have to move it. There is a story of 2 quite strong players playing a game in a tournament. One of the players grabbed a bishop to move it, realized "too late" that it was a blunder. Thinking fast he put it into his coffee to stir it pretending he picked up the bishop instead of his spoon by mistake. He was permitted to play a different move instead. I played in a blitz tournament and had my 2 bishops next to each other. I picked up the wrong one and tried to move it to the wrong color square. I looked up at my opponent and said, "I picked up the wrong bishop by mistake." He nodded and I played the other bishop to the square. No argument. No problem. He was a strong player who understood the rules. In your case, you had intended to move it a moment before and so it was perhaps not——clear——that touching it was an accident. If that is the case, in a tournament you're screwed. In a game between friends, it would seem he/she should take your word for it that touching it was accidental. On the other hand, you ought to abide by the rules as they would be enforced in a tournament. He has some justification for expecting that. Alternatively, perhaps your opponent thinks that any piece that is touched must be moved whether it was accidental or not. If that is the case, he/she is making a common and honest mistake. My recommendation is that since these are informal games, just resign on the spot. Don't turn it into an ego thing. It's no big deal. Play another game and have fun.
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.