Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: The advantage is too obvious with book and without Book (Experiment)

Author: Jorge Pichard

Date: 00:48:54 07/16/04


The advantage is too obvious with book and without Book, Jonny 2.64 doen't have
a chance against an opponent of equal strength like Aristarch 4.50. Therefore, I
simply stopped this unfair match. If anybody like to compare engines they would
have to match them by providing both programs with equal weapons :-)

[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2004.07.15"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Aristarch 4.50"]
[Black "Jonny 2.64"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "C42"]
[Opening "Petrov"]
[Time "20:52:57"]
[Variation "Damiano Variation"]
[TimeControl "600+5"]
[Comment " white engine resigns for black (illegal)"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "117"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.e4 e5 {-0.07/11 15} 2.Nf3 Nf6 {-0.16/11 13} 3.Nxe5 Qe7 {-0.19/11 12} 4.d4

d6
{-0.20/12 22} 5.Nf3 Qxe4+ {-0.20/11 14} 6.Be2 Be7 {-0.46/10 21} 7.O-O

{+0.90/11 10} O-O
{-0.39/10 18} 8.Re1 {+0.93/11 11} Qg4 {-0.64/10 12} 9.Nc3 {+0.98/11 11} Re8

{-0.58/10 12}
10.h3 {+0.88/11 11} Qd7 {-0.64/11 28} 11.d5 {+0.90/11 53} h6 {-0.73/10 20}

12.Bf4
{+0.95/11 26} c6 {-0.74/10 21} 13.Qd2 {+1.12/11 66} Qc7 {-0.70/10 20}

14.dxc6 {+1.32/9 7}
Nxc6 {-0.62/10 10} 15.Nb5 {+1.20/11 77} Qb6 {-0.82/10 9} 16.Bd3 {+1.44/10

17} a6
{-0.58/10 17} 17.Nxd6 {+1.48/10 3} Bxd6 {-0.42/10 8} 18.Bxd6 {+1.47/9 1}

Rxe1+ {-0.42/11
8} 19.Rxe1 {+1.63/10 1} Qxb2 {-0.53/11 8} 20.Ne5 {+1.45/10 5} Qb6 {-0.58/10

9}
21.Nc4 {+1.42/11 20} Qa7 {-0.38/11 14} 22.Bf4 {+1.40/11 11} Be6 {-0.77/10

36} 23.Be3
{+1.76/12 25} Qb8 {-0.64/12 11} 24.Bxh6 {+1.67/11 9} gxh6 {-2.56/11 34}

25.Qxh6 {+3.61/11
5} Qf8 {-2.32/10 26} 26.Qxf6 {+3.65/11 8} Qg7 {-2.59/11 12} 27.Qh4 {+3.70/10

6}
Rd8 {-2.34/10 9} 28.Re3 {+3.61/10 8} Kf8 {-2.67/9 23} 29.Qf4 {+3.73/9 2} Rd4
{-2.35/9 9} 30.Qc7 {+2.84/13 56} Qf6 {-2.37/11 10} 31.Ne5 {+2.76/10 7} Qe7

{-2.10/11 7}
32.Qb6 {+2.52/10 4} Rb4 {-2.16/12 6} 33.Nxc6 {+2.50/12 4} Rxb6 {-2.20/14 7}

34.Nxe7
{+2.68/12 3} Rb1+ {-2.37/15 22} 35.Kh2 {+2.73/13 5} Kxe7 {-2.37/15 13} 36.a3

{+2.61/12 7}
Kd6 {-2.32/12 5} 37.h4 {+3.60/12 6} Ra1 {-2.48/12 13} 38.Be4 {+3.51/12 7}

Rf1
{-2.61/12 6} 39.f3 {+3.54/12 13} Rb1 {-2.60/13 8} 40.g4 {+3.77/12 26} b6

{-2.60/11 6}
41.h5 {+4.56/11 4} Ke7 {-4.29/12 23} 42.h6 {+5.02/11 2} Rd1 {-4.29/14 5}

43.Rd3
{+5.07/11 1} Rxd3 {-4.47/15 10} 44.cxd3 {+5.66/12 1} Kf8 {-4.37/15 5} 45.d4

{+5.66/12 3}
Bb3 {-4.24/15 6} 46.d5 {+6.09/11 1} f6 {-5.62/14 6} 47.f4 {+6.93/11 1} Ba4
{-7.76/14 10} 48.g5 {+11.06/11 1} fxg5 {-11.63/14 12} 49.fxg5 {+11.48/10}

Bd1 {-11.48/12
7} 50.g6 {+13.16/12 2} Bb3 {-13.58/11 6} 51.g7+ {+21.10/12 10} Kg8

{-21.70/13 7}
52.Kg3 {+21.52/12 2} b5 {-20.72/12 7} 53.d6 {+24.21/10} Kf7 {-20.96/13 6}

54.h7
{+59.89/14 5} Kxg7 {-M5/14 5} 55.d7 {+59.91/15} Bf7 {-M4/15 10} 56.d8=Q

{+59.93/31 3} Be8
{-M3/15 10} 57.Qxe8 {+59.95/31 1} Kf6 {-M2/15 7} 58.h8=Q+ {+59.97/31 1} Kg5

{-M1/19 4}
59.Qg7# {+59.99/31 1}  {Mate} 1-0

[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2004.07.15"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Jonny 2.64"]
[Black "Aristarch 4.50"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D02"]
[Opening "Queen's Bishop Game"]
[Time "21:15:53"]
[TimeControl "600+5"]
[Comment " black engine resigns for white (illegal)"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "96"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1.d4 {+0.16/12 26} Nf6 2.Bf4 {+0.26/12 27} d5 3.Nc3 {+0.24/12 49} Bf5 4.e3
{+0.20/11 13} e6 {-0.19/10 11} 5.Bd3 {+0.21/11 35} Bxd3 {-0.23/12 100}

6.Qxd3 {+0.16/12
28} Nc6 {-0.23/10 6} 7.Nf3 {+0.09/11 41} Bd6 {-0.12/11 41} 8.Bxd6 {+0.05/10

29}
Qxd6 {-0.03/10 4} 9.O-O {+0.05/11 12} O-O {-0.01/12 41} 10.Nb5 {+0.12/11 10}

Qe7
{0.00/11 9} 11.c4 {+0.07/11 18} Ne4 {+0.16/10 12} 12.Nc3 {+0.17/10 12} Nxc3

{+0.06/11
21} 13.Qxc3 {+0.19/11 11} Rfd8 {0.00/11 42} 14.Rfc1 {+0.22/10 27} a5

{+0.06/11 31}
15.cxd5 {+0.32/10 8} Rxd5 {+0.14/11 25} 16.e4 {+0.34/11 20} Rd7 {+0.20/10 7}

17.Qb3
{+0.14/10 14} Nxd4 {+0.58/12 42} 18.Nxd4 {+0.04/12 11} Rxd4 {+0.58/11 2}

19.Qxb7
{+0.11/12 8} Rad8 {+0.53/10 8} 20.g3 {+0.02/12 25} Qf6 {+0.48/13 48} 21.Qxc7

{+0.33/11 8}
R4d2 {+0.48/12 6} 22.Rcf1 {+0.36/12 7} Qxb2 {+0.31/11 10} 23.Qxa5 {+0.29/12

16} Qd4
{+0.33/10 6} 24.Rab1 {+0.73/12 9} h5 {+0.25/12 40} 25.Rb4 {+0.88/12 6} Qc3

{+0.52/10 5}
26.a4 {+0.87/11 7} h4 {+0.27/10 5} 27.Kg2 {+0.97/10 8} Qa3 {+0.16/10 29}

28.gxh4
{+1.39/11 7} Qc3 {+0.34/10 3} 29.Qb5 {+1.25/12 14} Ra2 {0.00/12 20} 30.Rc4

{+1.29/12 10}
Qd3 {0.00/12 4} 31.Qb4 {+1.07/10 7} Qe2 {+0.70/10 5} 32.h3 {+0.06/10 11}

Rad2
{+0.69/9 2} 33.Qb5 {+0.42/11 15} Kh7 {+1.22/11 14} 34.Rb4 {+0.71/11 10} R8d3

{+4.40/10
1} 35.Kg1 {-4.32/8 5} Rg3+ {+7.12/10} 36.Kh2 {-5.11/12 22} Qf3 {+7.64/10}

37.Qh5+
{-7.21/13 7} Qxh5 {+10.03/12 1} 38.Kxg3 {-7.21/13 21} Rd3+ {+12.55/10 1}

39.f3 {-11.30/10
5} Rd2 {+12.99/10} 40.Rf2 {-11.54/10 5} Qg6+ {+17.80/9} 41.Kf4 {-17.72/11 8}

Rxf2
{+18.63/9} 42.Ke3 {-M7/10 19} Qg3 {+59.81/8 1} 43.Kd3 {-M6/10 4} Rxf3+

{+59.89/11 16}
44.Kc4 {-M5/13 4} Rc3+ {+59.91/13 6} 45.Kb5 {-M4/15 5} Qb8+ {+59.93/14}

46.Ka6 {-M3/16
9} Rc6+ {+59.95/16 5} 47.Ka5 {-M2/17 4} Qa8+ {+59.97/15 5} 48.Kb5 {-M1/18 7}

Qa6#
{+59.99/31}  {Mate} 0-1


[Event "Arena tournament"]
[Site "S0025128408"]
[Date "2004.07.15"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Aristarch 4.50"]
[Black "Jonny 2.64"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D38"]
[Opening "QGD"]



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.