Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Bob: ELChinito a clone from Crafty ... Free and Commercial

Author: Rolf Tueschen

Date: 11:21:59 08/22/04

Go up one level in this thread


On August 22, 2004 at 11:44:07, Jonas Bylund wrote:

>On August 22, 2004 at 08:05:33, Rolf Tueschen wrote:
>
>>I give you a serious hint, Frank. You are a businessman and you already use
>>ElChinito in combination with one of your products. You cannot pretend to be
>>innocent as long as no clear "proof" did exist that ElChinito is a clone. If you
>>are using it however you should be very certain that it's NOT a clone. It all
>>falls back on you as the businessman, because if it's a clone, the programmers
>>might be far out of reach for possible recompensations. So you should be a bit
>>more interested into the details of the question.
>>
>>IMO you can't take the opinion that you are sober when you "use" this program as
>>long as it's not clearly proven that it's a clone. Sorry for that position, but
>>before you are hirt in your business interests, you should carefully check the
>>here given position. I hope this helps you.
>>
>>A good idea could be that your programmers hat to certify you that their product
>>is NO clone of Crafty. If then this is proven as a lie, then you have best
>>chances to be out of troubles.
>
>As far as i know, El Chinito is not being sold with arena?

RUFFIAN wasn't sold either but then suddenly a bundle *was* sold with RUFFIAN2
in combination with ARENA. I dont know about ElChinito. But guess Frank makes a
new bundle including ElChinito AND then it could be proven that it's a stolen
Crafty THEN Frank could get into troubles. Hope this helps you. I didn't know
that everything had to be outspoken for academics. Sorry.
I wrote I wanted to give Frank a serious "hint". Do you want to claim that my
hint was wrong? I just commented because I saw that Frank had a wrong handling
in mind.

[Just for your interest: we had a similar case months ago. Then it was about the
package number one and Frank asked here in CCC if that was ok how how he did the
correction for the claim on his packaging. Yes he asked but then he reacted in
that same manner meaning something like "basically Frank knows better what is
good for Frank" although many here explained in detail why he was wrong... BTW I
bet that we will see that soon a second bundle will be offered _commercially_
and that now is all good PR for FQ, at least how he understands himself as
businessman. Funny. Interesting how FREE products mutate into commercial
products.]



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.