Author: Michael Henderson
Date: 10:21:26 10/11/04
Go up one level in this thread
Why are losing captures a significant part of your cutoffs? Do you order them before the quiet moves and how does your SEE score losing captures? Also you have to ask yourself what is the hash move--winning capture, =capture, losing capture, since it is just another move. You might want to distribute "hash move" into the other moves for consistency. On October 11, 2004 at 08:53:30, Rick Bischoff wrote: >Hello, > >I have been trying to get my move ordering right, and am running into the >following anomalies-- was wondering if your engine has the same rates; >basically, if the score is above alpha (even if it is above beta), I increment a >counter for the type of move. > >I currently count hash moves, winning captures, =captures, losing captures, >killers, history and everything else. > >I ran the full WAC test at a fixed depth of 6 and the following happens; > >for every position: > >hash cutoffs are around 15-40% >winning captures are around 40-73% >even captures are ALWAYS 0% (but I still have some, just not enough to be >= 1%) >losing captures are around 10% >killers are around 1% >history are around 0% >and other are 3% > >I *must* have a bug-- it makes sense to me that hash cutoffs should be much >bigger than winning captures shoud be much bigger than even captures should be >bigger than losing captures, etc. > >One scenario that I could think of was that the search kept changing its mind >during the next iteration, but surely this shouldn't happen enough to account >for the large difference. > >From the opening position with a fixed depth of 8 with material only eval: > >1,197,470 nodes >242162 cutoffs >9% hash (23260) >34% winning captures (82780) >0% even captures (61) >22% losing captures (54077) >31% killers (75561) >0% history (71) >2% other (6352) > >with full eval: > >1,492,098 nodes >295234 cutoffs >8% hash (25776) >37% winning captures (111206) >0% even captures (109) >24% losing captures (70898) >25% killers (76224) >0% history (290) >3% other (10731)
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.