Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: celeron A 450 vs pentium ll 450

Author: Rajen Gupta

Date: 02:58:16 01/17/99

Go up one level in this thread


Dear bob:
perhaps the lifespan of the chip may be reduced, but as I have spent only £60 on
I'mm not too concrened becuse by then I would probably have moved much to much
further speeds (hopefully againby overclocking)

Rajen Gupta

On January 16, 1999 at 21:21:07, Robert Hyatt wrote:

>On January 16, 1999 at 18:31:18, Rajen Gupta wrote:
>
>>I recently built a new computer with 128megs ram and the celeron 300A processor
>>(great buy at £60)which i have successfully overclocked to 450 MHz.It has been
>>running stable at this speed (I ran F5 and CM5000 simultaneously, continuously
>>overnight for last 3 nights to test the stability of the overclocked chip.) I
>>got the following values for fritz mark and junior mark:
>>
>>FRITZ MARK short   316  KN/sec=392 (16 Mb hash tables)
>>
>>FRITZ MARK long    291  KN/sec=434 (96Mb hash tables)
>>
>>JUNIOR MARK short  307  KN/sec=381 (20 mb hash tables)
>>
>>JUNIOR MARK long   332  Kn/sec 373 (96mb hash tables)  I wonder how these values
>>compare with a genuine pentium ll 450 or 400 MHz or even a top of the line AMD
>>K6? would the extra 512 kb of cache running at 1/2 speed out perform 128 kb
>>running at full speed? I wonder if people with such systems could let me know?
>>even perhaps a comparison could be made between Cel A vs pentium ll vs AMD for
>>different programmes. Interestingly CM5000 calculates 25-28000 posn with every
>>blink.I'll try to boost this chip to 500mhz and if it runs stable I'll post
>>figures at this speed as well.
>>
>>Rajen Gupta
>
>Two parts to this answer.  The celeronA can be better than the PII, but it
>depends.  The PII at 450 has 512kb of L2 cache running at 225mhz.  The
>CeleronA has 128kb of L2 running at 450mhz (assuming you overclock to 450mhz).
>
>That may or may not make it faster.  For small compact programs (ie like Fritz)
>this might be a better deal.
>
>But be aware that when you overclock temperatures rise.  And the L2 cache is
>really taking a beating.  Although I really believe that the L2 in the celeron
>is the same type technology as in the 450, so it probably won't hurt it much.
>
>But I'm not a big overclocking fan.  ON the linux SMP kernel mailing list, I
>hear horror stories every day about how this causes odd behavior...  and causes
>problems that are not always 'solid'.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.