Author: Peter Berger
Date: 18:12:07 12/05/04
Go up one level in this thread
On December 05, 2004 at 17:51:39, Matthew Hull wrote: >On December 05, 2004 at 14:08:25, Uri Blass wrote: > >>On December 05, 2004 at 13:31:55, Thomas Gaksch wrote: >> >>>On December 02, 2004 at 17:21:21, Wilhelm Hudetz wrote: >>> >>>>Hi all, >>>> >>>>what are your results with different Crafty versions? >>>>19.08SE give me at the moment the best results, so I run a small >>>>tourney to compare a little bit. >>>>All SE-versions run with SE=on and standard personality. >>>> >>>>AMD3200 >>>>Arena-GUI >>>>64mb hash >>>>all using 8move.abk >>>>3,4,5man tb´s >>>>time 5+5 >>>> >>>> Motor Punkte Li Cr Cr CM Pa Cr Cr Cr Cr >>>>Cr S-B >>>>01: List 5.12 24,0/36 ···· =011 =010 11=0 1001 1==1 1011 1110 =110 >>>>1111 397,50 >>>>02: Crafty 19.08 SE 24,0/36 =100 ···· ==== 01== ==== =111 =1=1 111= 1=1= >>>>11=1 389,75 >>>>03: Crafty 19.12 SE 22,5/36 =101 ==== ···· =11= =010 ==01 10=1 1=01 111= >>>>==11 381,00 >>>>04: CM8000 R1X 21,0/36 00=1 10== =00= ···· 1=== 001= =1== 1==1 =111 >>>>111= 339,25 >>>>05: Patriot 1.3.0 19,5/36 0110 ==== =101 0=== ···· =0=1 1=== =00= 1=11 >>>>101= 339,50 >>>>06: Crafty 17.14 17,5/36 0==0 =000 ==10 110= =1=0 ···· ==== 1=01 =111 >>>>=0== 293,75 >>>>07: Crafty Classic 2004 16,0/36 0100 =0=0 01=0 =0== 0=== ==== ···· 10=1 011= >>>>1=10 266,25 >>>>08: Crafty 19.17 SE 13,0/36 0001 000= 0=10 0==0 =11= 0=10 01=0 ···· 0010 >>>>0011 233,00 >>>>09: Crafty 15.18 11,5/36 =001 0=0= 000= =000 0=00 =000 100= 1101 ···· >>>>=101 190,75 >>>>10: Crafty 11.23 11,0/36 0000 00=0 ==00 000= 010= =1== 0=01 1100 =010 >>>>···· 185,25 >>>> >>>>180 Partien gespielt / Turnier beendet >>>>Name des Turniers: EngineMatch >>>>Ort/ Land: Vienna, Austria >>>>Level: Blitz 5/5 >>>>Hardware: AMD Athlon(tm) XP 3200+ 2219 MHz mit 1.023 MB Speicher >>>>Betriebssystem: Microsoft Windows XP Professional Service Pack 2 (Build 2600) >>>>PGN-Datei: E:\SCHACH\Arena\Tournaments\EngineMatch.pgn >>>>Webseite: >>>>E-Mail Adresse: >>>> >>>>regards >>>>Wilhelm >>> >>> >>>it would be nice to read an comment from DR. Robert Hyatt or Mike Byrne about >>>the strongest version. >>>In my tests Crafty Classic 2004 is much stronger than Crafty 19.17. An the >>>strange thing is, that Crafty 19.17 seems to be weaker than the other "old" >>>Crafty Versions (19.13 and 19.08). >>> >>>regards >>>Thomas >> >>Nothing strange. >> >>I read that every tester found that 19.17 is weaker. >>The problem is that it seems that Hyatt did not test Crafty under winboard or >>under interfaces that other use it. > > >Even on ICC, 19.17 is definitely weaker against other computers. It's average >blitz rating has dropped a good 150 points or more since shortly after WCCC04, >which was the advent of the 19.16/17 versions. > >After hearing other claims that 19.13 was stronger, I started a 100 game match >between 19.13 and 19.17 at 30 0. > >19.13 is demolishing 19.17 with the score currently at 41 24 after 65 games. >This right after 19.16 vs 19.17 was virtually even after 100 games. > >Something is seriously wrong with 19.17. > Given that this may be true IMO , you should go for 19.15. 19.15 is mostly bugfixes compaired to 19.13, some of them quite serious. In case I had to bet on a Crafty version, it would be 19.15 - this is also the very WCCC version btw.
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.