Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: AMD Athlon or Pentium 4??

Author: Frank Quisinsky

Date: 05:13:08 12/12/04

Go up one level in this thread


On December 12, 2004 at 07:58:58, Sandro Necchi wrote:

Hi Sandro,

>Well, since 8 years I stop buying Intel processors mainly for chess as the AMD
>processors were, in my opinion going to get better (cheaper and faster) than
>Intel ones. Which became true recently. The Intel ones I used where only at
>work.

Faster isn't OK in my opinion.
The Athlon system are fast (also clear for me) but 10% more or less isn't
important for the most customers. The new PIV generation is very fast, I have
here different programs which are faster on my Pentium IV Mobile Notebook with
2.67 if I compare only with Athlon 2.8 Barton.

But look on your latest sentence :-)
I must daily work on my PC systems (of course, not only chess for the freeware
area) :-)

Cheaper:
That is a big, a very big point!
AMD are not so expensive and a good reason why younger persons like Athlon
processors. This is a new generation and a big problem for Intel. Intel must go
the right way and have to make the processors more cheaper or Intel have a
generation problem!

>Well, I must say that I never had problems with AMD even if the computer where
>placed in a warm room especially in summer.

The combination from all what have to do with the temparature.
Not only problems with the processors, thinking on harddisk, cooler other
things.

>Considering that all my computers are going all the time I was quite satisfied
>with them.
>
>Recently my company hardware expert told me that he is now buying only AMD
>processors as more quiet and reliable. This is due to the high frequency of
>Intel last processors which make them less reliable if one uses them several
>hours every day.

Oh, we have totally different computer experts :-)
Same in the user selection we can read each day :-)

My computer expert sayed (have the same opinion) I build each system and I have
to look for the best hardware constellation that booth systems works fine for
the customers. If a company with 20 systems for a network room with Athlon
processors (never heard this, but posssible, why not) the expert I know for sell
20 Athlons and try to find a good hardware combination.

In my live I working in more as 30 network rooms, more as 10 machines are here.
All of them are Intel systems the most easy Celeron systems.

>It seems to me that only the latest Centrino processor is worth for Intel, so it
>is hard for me to understand who is pushing for Intel processors recently.

Not for me Sandro!
But I sayed it ... the Athlon processors are now clearly better if I compare
with the older Athlons, like 1.2, or 1.4 with a lot of problems.

Just my opinion and experience.
>
>Sandro

Best
Frank



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.