Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: What contrbution is it, besides statistics?

Author: stuart taylor

Date: 03:58:23 12/31/04

Go up one level in this thread


On December 31, 2004 at 00:56:53, Kurt Utzinger wrote:

>On December 30, 2004 at 20:05:55, stuart taylor wrote:
>
>>I'm always interested in two things. 1).What the results are statistically, and
>>2). What does this machine contribute by the way it plays, which another does
>>not? It's not enough if it has nice ideas which lose because they are unsound.
>>But I'm talking about real strong play which only loses because of certain
>>little problems, but the concepts being great.
>> Juniors recent results are great enough that, if they were attained with great
>>attacking play, then I would feel that if it was the same, but with LESS
>>attacking play, then it would have higher results than Shredder and Hiarcs. i.e.
>>the attacking play caused a little risk which calmer great programs can exploit.
>>
>>But what about Hiarcs 9? Maybe THAT is more qualitative than Junior 9? Maybe
>>not!
>>
>>So what do I get from playing through Junior 9 games, which I gedt less of, from
>>others?
>
>
>      Hi Stuart
>      You are right: results and statistics are one thing, the
>      way how engines play another thing. Well, with Junior9
>      you have a fine engine that is in particular very very
>      strong in dynamic positions. Junior9 seems to know much
>      about compensation and the games are quite often amazing:
>      Junior9 sees some advantage other engines can't evaluate
>      correctly and quite often his opponents are ambushed and
>      their evaluation suck at once from a very positive to a
>      negative score. You will simply have great fun with Junior9
>      I can promise you. It's a must to have engine -:)
>      Kurt [http://www.utzingerk.com]

If I want only ONE engine for this display of chess wisdom, would I take Hiarcs
9, or Junior 9?
I suppose it's hard to answer this with all programmers watching what you (or
anyone) is saying. But so are some of the top consumers.
S.Taylor



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.