Author: Vasik Rajlich
Date: 11:40:45 02/13/05
Go up one level in this thread
On February 12, 2005 at 17:30:49, Rafael Peña wrote: >Hello! > >After seeing the official resul vs crafty, i've decided take out my program from >CCT7. > >here are my reason: > >1.- The game vs crafty, both engines says draw (look the position, and score >from crafty and fafis). >2.- Crafty offer several times draw to Fafis. >3.- Fafis accepted the draw and i Communicated to the chanel 64 on ICC. >4.- Arena (debug window) and Fafis put in their log draw by mutual agrement. >5.- 10 min later , TD says that Fafis lost on time. > >Is a good tourney and excellent organitation, but i'm not agree with this >choice, i lost the game vs zappa because i have not internet conetion at home, >so is my fault, but i don't see why the game is lose by fafis vs crafty, i think >the tourney it's for fun or somebody is going to win money?. > >I'm not sure is if Arena bug or ICC bug as some people said, i think the >decision is based on what happened (that is my 5 reasons), TD said that is based >on ICC log. > >Some people said in a bad way that i'll be in a black list for leave the >tourney, i think, i said in a very polite way to td that i was leaving out the >tourney, and i made appologies to all people in cct7. > >I don't going said more about this, also i don't think aswers replies here, just >i'm posting here with my reason. > >GL on CCT7. >Rafael Peña >Program. Fafis IMHO in a situation like this, the TD/ruling committee should do everything in his/their power to mark the game as its rightful result - ie. a draw. Only way it should be a win is if the rules are 100% clear and leave absolutely zero room for interpretation - and in this case the rules should be revised. Otherwise CC will just get a bad name .. Vas
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.