Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: S9 Book

Author: Ingo Bauer

Date: 12:00:53 02/16/05

Go up one level in this thread


>The co-author of the UCI standard doesn't use the "own book" option for his
>engine/book. Even Gandalf has this option. I will guarantee if Hiarcs becomes
>available as UCI, it will support this.

IIRC: In the beginning UCI was designed as "stateless", which means that the
engine does not know anything about the game itself. Because many programmers
demanded the possibility to use their own book the "own book" feature was
implemented (as the "usinewgame" feature was implemented shortly).

>It is almost a proprietary move to force people to use your interface, yet in
>the same regard it isn't because you allow the engine to be used elsewhere, but
>the book is locked.

In the meantime we now that you do not like the decision but your reasoning is a
bit odd to me. With the same argument you could deny to buy any Chessbase engine
because the book is completly handled by the the CB-GUI AND the Engines are not
able to run somewhere else. It seems Chessbase is "forcing" you to their
interface even more. Will you argue against their decisions with the same effort
OR will you buy S9 from Shredderchess if Stefan is offering you a S9 version
that is able only to run in the Classic interface? I doubt that this question
needs an answer!

I think i have said all I can in this matter!

Bye
Ingo Bauer





This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.