Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Chess program similarity experiment (Results)

Author: Bruce Moreland

Date: 10:26:47 01/28/99

Go up one level in this thread


I have some results for Crafty 15.20.  It looks a little more like Bionic than
other programs do, except for Bionic itself.

This may be because of the faster processor.  I'd stil like to see runs for the
version that Bionic was based on, and I think it would make sense to do a run
with Crafty on something slower, perhaps Bionic on something faster, and I'll
try to run mine on something faster as well.  I also want to get the rest of
Bob's 15.20 run, to see how well it matches versus the opponents.

This test is going to have problems because of the different processor types,
but I still think I'd rather be able to compare a P6/200 at one minute versus a
Xeon 450 x 4 at one minute, rather than running the P6/200 for 8 minutes or the
quad Xeon for 8 seconds.

bruce

--------------------

                  Ferret     Exchess    Amateur    Zarkov
                  v 546      v 2.53     v 0.9h     v 4.5c
                  P6/200     Cel/400    G3/300     P2/300
                  49mb       24mb                  2mb
       Rd Total
Bionic  1   60    36  60%    34  57%    33  55%    33  55%
        2   38    12  32%    13  34%    11  29%    10  26%
        3   30    22  73%    22  73%    23  77%    26  87%
        4   40    27  68%    25  63%    27  68%    30  75%
        5   17    15  88%    10  59%     9  53%    13  76%
        6   44    29  66%    32  73%    29  66%    30  68%
        7   53    28  53%    31  58%    30  57%    29  55%
        8   47    28  60%    23  49%    26  55%    30  64%
        9   32    26  81%    25  78%    24  75%    25  78%
       10   22    16  73%    16  73%    17  77%    18  82%
       11   22    16  73%    12  55%    14  64%    16  73%
           405   255  63%   243  60%   243  60%   260  64%

Opp.    1   60    30  50%    24  40%    16  27%    20  33%
        2   38    14  37%    11  29%    12  32%    22  58%
        3   30    20  67%    24  80%    16  53%    17  57%
        4   39    18  46%    15  38%    16  41%    23  59%
        5   17    12  71%     9  53%     9  53%    13  76%
        6   43    27  63%    25  58%    22  51%    30  70%
        7   54    34  63%    27  50%    27  50%    35  65%
        8   47    31  66%    26  55%    21  45%    36  77%
        9   31    19  61%    24  77%    20  65%    18  58%
       10   21     5  24%     6  29%     9  43%     6  29%
       11   22     9  41%    10  45%     7  32%     8  36%
           402   219  54%   201  50%   175  44%   228  57%


                  Bionic     Crafty
                  v4.01      v 15.20
                  K6/333     4x450
                  48mb       96/20
       Rd Total
Bionic  1   60    40  67%    40  67%
        2   38    24  63%    12  32%
        3   30    28  93%    26  87%
        4   40    37  93%    31  78%
        5   17    14  82%    15  88%
        6   44    38  86%    36  82%
        7   53    38  72%    35  66%
        8   47    33  70%    37  79%
        9   32    27  84%    27  84%
       10   22    17  77%    19  86%
       11   22    17  77%    18  82%
           405   313  77%   296  73%

Opp.    1   60    32  53%
        2   38    14  37%
        3   30    20  67%
        4   39    26  67%
        5   17    10  59%
        6   43    26  60%
        7   54    29  54%
        8   47    21  45%
        9   31    21  68%
       10   21    10  48%
       11   22    10  45%
           402   219  54%



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.