Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Clarify the 2nd stage Fredkin Prize award! Explain how..

Author: Rolf Tueschen

Date: 04:54:38 04/29/05

Go up one level in this thread


On April 29, 2005 at 07:35:02, chandler yergin wrote:

>On April 28, 2005 at 12:19:58, chandler yergin wrote:
>
>>The Fredkin Prize
>>
>>It was a three stage prize.  The first for the author of the first computer to
>>achieve a master chess rating.  Awarded to Belle in 1983.  The second for the
>>first program to produce a 2600 performance rating over 25 consecutive games
>>against grandmaster players in long (40 moves in 2 hours or slower) games.
>>Awarded to deep thought in the early 1990's.  The final stage was to beat the
>>world champion in a match.  Awarded to IBM in 1997.
>>
>>  "The Computers Won" all three stages..
>
>Apparently not! Someone has some explaining to do!
>
>
>>
>>Congratulations to the winners!
>
>Question:
>The second stage Prize, as noted was 'awarded' to deep thought in the 1990's.
>
>The Rules were that it was to be awarded to the first program to produce a 2600
>performance rating over 25 consecutive games against Grandmaster players
>in long (40 moves in 2 hours or slower) games.
>
>This is the Performance record of Deep Thought:
>
>page 1 of 1; 24 games
>
>Game   Result Moves Year Event/Locale Opening
>1. Alburt vs Deep Thought  1-0 61 1988 10, USA op-Boston D25 Queen's Gambit
>Accepted
>2. Deep Thought vs Browne   0-1 36 1988 Software Toolworks Ch Pittsburgh PA USA
>B22 Sicilian, Alapin
>3. Igor Ivanov vs Deep Thought   1/2-1/2 44 1988 Ohio A22 English
>4. Deep Thought vs Igor Ivanov  1-0 29 1988 Long Beach Californ B01 Scandinavian
>5. E Trice vs Deep Thought  1-0 20 1989 Training game B13 Caro-Kann, Exchange
>6. Deep Thought vs M Valvo  0-1 48 1989 cr C31 King's Gambit Declined, Falkbeer
>Counter Gambit
>7. Deep Thought vs K Spraggett   1/2-1/2 48 1989 Edmonton D01 Richter-Veresov
>Attack
>8. Miles vs Deep Thought  0-1 38 1989 Long Beach D20 Queen's Gambit Accepted
>9. Kasparov vs Deep Thought  1-0 37 1989 New York D20 Queen's Gambit Accepted
>10. Deep Thought vs Alburt  0-1 40 1989 1st Harvard Cup 3 G/ B03 Alekhine's
>Defense
>11. Larsen vs Deep Thought  0-1 43 1989 Long Beach A00 Uncommon Opening
>12. Gulko vs Deep Thought  1-0 29 1989 1st Harvard Cup 1 G/ A00 Uncommon Opening
>13. Deep Thought vs Kasparov  0-1 52 1989 New York B22 Sicilian, Alapin
>14. Karpov vs Deep Thought  1-0 65 1990 Harvard ,CBM 17 B12 Caro-Kann Defense
>15. Deep Thought vs Bronstein  1-0 22 1992 Game in 15' C31 King's Gambit
>Declined, Falkbeer Counter Gambit
>16. Bronstein vs Deep Thought  1-0 25 1992 New York B20 Sicilian
>17. Deep Thought vs Bronstein  1-0 21 1992 Nevada C39 King's Gambit Accepted
>18. Deep Thought vs Joel Benjamin   1/2-1/2 48 1993 03, 6/93 ICS Heid C08
>French, Tarrasch, Open, 4.ed ed
>19. Joel Benjamin vs Deep Thought  0-1 64 1993 02, 6/93 ICS Heid C69 Ruy Lopez,
>Exchange, Gligoric Variation, 6.d4
>20. Joel Benjamin vs Deep Thought   0-1 39 1993 06, 6/93 ICS Heid C80 Ruy Lopez,
>Open
>21. Deep Thought vs Joel Benjamin   1-0 53 1993 01, 6/93-53 ICS Heid B46
>Sicilian, Taimanov Variation
>22. Deep Thought vs Joel Benjamin   1-0 43 1993 05, 6/93 ICS Heid B06 Robatsch
>23. Joel Benjamin vs Deep Thought  1-0 41 1993 04, 6/93-55 ICS Heid D35 Queen's
>Gambit Declined
>24. Deep Thought vs Zarkov   1-0 41 1994 24th ACM Computer Chess Champi C39
>King's Gambit Accepted
>
> page 1 of 1; 24 games
>
>
>Obviously, Deep Thought did not even come close to meeting the Rules
>for any Prize!  This is outrageous.


Nope!

If you count in all the wins Deep Thought had against players like Ed Trice and
Rolf Tueschen - THEN the Fredkin Prize is more than justified! It was the
hardest job and it lasted almost decades...

But why bringing up all such unneccessary details? I dont understand you, Chan!
Are you a muckraker?

;)



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.