Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: More Adam vs Hydra Hype

Author: Vincent Lejeune

Date: 11:53:42 05/26/05

Go up one level in this thread


On May 26, 2005 at 12:02:37, Vincent Diepeveen wrote:

>On May 26, 2005 at 10:40:04, Darrel Briley wrote:
>
>>There's another article on Chessbase site today concerning the upcoming match.
>>
>>http://www.chessbase.com/newsdetail.asp?newsid=2412
>>
>>It's interesting to note that despite the upcoming Adams/Leko match beginning
>>June 2nd (a rapid match), the match with Hydra is getting all the press.  Some
>>highlights from the article:
>>
>>...processing power equivalent to more than 200 standard PCs
>
>32 pc processors
>
>Please prove me that such a simple program like hydra cannot search with
>millions of nodes a second single cpu in software. Even crafty can get what is
>it 2+ million nps at an opteron or so?
>
>Additional it's without hashtables last X plies and very poor move ordering
>techniques in hardware (it does have killer moves as opposed to deep blue, so
>it's *far more* efficient in hardware than DB was at its days).
>
>>...64-way cluster computer
>
>32 processors used though. I'm sure it would be more effective when run in
>software. However would you have written this posting then?
>
>>...16 nodes of four computers, with each node boasting 32GB of memory
>
>Not used last 6 plies or so in search.
>
>>...Each computer has an Intel Xeon 3.06 Ghz.
>
>Irrelevant, search is in hardware.
>
>>...It has never been beaten by a human.
>
>Oh there is *many* programs that can say that with respect to official matches.
>
>>And some of the expamples provided to demonstrate Hydra's power:
>
>>-1 second to analyse 200 million chess moves and chose the best one. This
>
>Please note the node count of hydra is just guessed. There is not hardware
>beancounter. So he's just doing software nodes times some optimistic number of
>nodes a search which is guessed. And no doubt a factor 3 to 4 too much.
>
>>includes projecting the game 18-40 moves head (6 more than Deep Blue)
>
>Deep blue searched 10 ply search depth in crucial positions and up to 12 ply
>deep in other positions. Hydra will get double that depth. So that's 10 moves
>look ahead.
>
>>-1 millisecond to calculate all possible angles and determine whether Luis
>>Garcia’s shot was a goal in the Champions League semi-final
>>-1 second to match a finger print to any person within the UK
>
>No way, in any arabic state they're not clever enough to develop such techniques
>themselves :)
>
>>-Less than 1.5 minutes to match a finger print to any person in the world
>>-Approximately five minutes to calculate every prime number between 1 and 1x1051
>>(a sexdicillion)
>
>Hello, i can calculate prime numbers up to 10 million digits at my pc nearly,
>though not within 5 minutes.
>
>A prime number of 1051 digits is really peanuts to calculate within seconds.

Note that a sexdicillion is 10^51 (the "^" was lost somewhere)

>
>I'll have to refer to some other software mine there.
>
>Vincent



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.