Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: About Fafis...

Author: GŁnther Simon

Date: 09:17:29 05/28/05

Go up one level in this thread


On May 28, 2005 at 11:53:29, Peter Skinner wrote:

>On May 28, 2005 at 11:45:29, Eric Oldre wrote:
>
>>Peter,
>>I think the FEN string feature is the most convincing of all the evidence Alex
>>provides. I just don't see how someone writing their own engine from scratch
>>would duplicate that unless they either.
>>
>>a) took crafty source in it's entirety, and began modifing it
>>b) cut and paste the FEN parser from crafty directly.
>>c) copied the logic of the crafty parser line by line.
>>
>
>There have been others that took the book code, the learning code, the ICS
>noalias code...
>
>That doesn't make it a clone. It just means parts are taken from it, or
>referenced.
>
>>That combined with the other evidence provided I believe leaves the burden of
>>proof on Rafael. I think this evidence is much stronger than the evidence was
>>with either Toga or Patriot. (at least that which was posted here)
>
>Could be. I am not willing to just accept it is a clone. I remember talking to
>Rafael during the CCT, and he certainly knew his stuff about what was going on
>with his program and the techniques used to program it.
>
>>I have not personally downloaded the source yet. But others are indicating it
>>seems to be purposely obfuscated, and/or does not create the fafis 2.1
>>executable but a older version. This is another example of suspicious behavior
>>like the virus.
>>
>>Eric
>
>I explained how the virus _could_ have happened. I have not looked at the source
>at all. I just haven't had the time, but the proof offered here doesn't convince
>me. I _will_ eat crow if it is conclusively proven however :)
>
>Peter


There is no source to look in, except the source of an 1.5 years old version,
which was released last week. I fail to see the purpose of that action.
(This old version was hundreds of rating points weaker BTW)

Guenther



This page took 0.07 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 07 Jul 11 08:48:38 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.