Author: rasjid chan
Date: 01:13:40 06/18/05
Go up one level in this thread
On June 18, 2005 at 03:02:05, rasjid chan wrote: > >"I see no reason to ever fail hard. I don't even see how fail-soft is more >bug-prone" > >I think some(many?) don't use fail-soft because there is almost always >too long a "todo" list with high priority. > >If I am not wrong, after we get through with how to implement it correctly, it >"should be" bug free. Maybe the method may be summarize in just a few principles >to stick to, basically :- >1) when returning from any search(), return a return_type of ex/ub/lb/rep3 >2) when we store a best-score for exact, fail-low or fail-high,we > apply revere_type() which only reveresd the type of ub/lb. >3) when we fail-high and the "best_type" is ex and if the move happen >to be the last move left(more often in QS), we upgrade the return_type from the >usual lb for fail-high to ex. > >This may be "about all" and maybe some other finer details that most >chess programers should easily know. > >The problem is I have not monitored the "softness" of my fail soft. >If fail-soft is really soft to a fair degree, why should anyone "fall-hard". >When we store scores to HT, we may have a greater LB or lesser UB which >is always better. > >Regards >Rasjid I have just added added some lines to monitor the softness of my fail soft. It monitors all fail-low at the end of search() and qsearch() and no-move return for QS, ignoring forward prunning fail-low etc, using cumulative figure of sum-of-variation-from-alpha/total-fail-low-count playing a game with kiwi losing 0-1 the first move has:- soft-count = 6280 avg-variation = 60.55 (pawn-value = 100) game end has:- soft-count = 231983 avg-variation = 158.32 I have no idea of this "softness", but the figure is an encouraging non-zero! From the log-file below I also have my first-move-fail-high statisticof of about 90% using what, at my level, is fairly comprehensive specific move ordering deliberately avoiding any killer moves or history. I am nor sure if this figure is good-enough/bad? Best Regards Rasjid log file losing 0-1 to kiwi:- Search algorithm - plain AB Pawn Hash Size 1.50 MB, record size (24) bytes Hash Size 20.00 MB, record size 20, records 1048576 game 1 1 e7e5 1 e7e5 ( -4) d-full( 4) Iter( 4) nps( 37236) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.13 / 0) eHhit(0.14) PHhit(0.41) draw(0) fmFH(0.93 /10827) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.40) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.17) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 4376) soft(6280/ 60.55) 2 d8f6 2 g8f6 ( -35) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37701) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.13 / 0) eHhit(0.15) PHhit(0.45) draw(0) fmFH(0.93 /22641) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.35) ExEV(0.04)qExt(0.13) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3481) soft(14209/ 65.15) 3 f8a3 3 f6e4 ( -26) d-full( 3) Iter( 1) nps( 37494) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.07 / 0) eHhit(0.07) PHhit(0.47) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /34226) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.22) ExEV(0.09)qExt(0.05) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3824) soft(21677/ 78.05) 4 e4d2 4 d7d5 ( -91) d-full( 3) Iter( 1) nps( 38663) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.13 / 0) eHhit(0.14) PHhit(0.51) draw(0) fmFH(0.90 /44383) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.32) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.17) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3802) soft(27858/ 89.72) 5 d5d4 5 f8b4 ( -106) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38841) pvL( 7) targ(0) Hhit(0.18 / 1) eHhit(0.20) PHhit(0.52) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /50034) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.45) ExEV(0.09)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1997) soft(31385/ 88.16) 6 a7a6 6 b4d6 ( -140) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 39509) pvL( 6) targ(0) Hhit(0.30 / 0) eHhit(0.34) PHhit(0.45) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /56653) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.67) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2831) soft(35062/ 97.58) 7 d6g3 7 f7f5 ( -140) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 39219) pvL( 0) targ(0) Hhit(0.12 / 1) eHhit(0.13) PHhit(0.57) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /62249) pvStage(0) maxD(11) fnodes(0.62) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2020) soft(38574/106.80) 8 g7g6 8 d5e4 ( -140) d-full( 4) Iter( 0) nps( 39055) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.14 / 0) eHhit(0.14) PHhit(0.56) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /68941) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.49) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2313) soft(42854/109.48) 9 e4e3 9 b8c6 ( -150) d-full( 3) Iter( 1) nps( 38729) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.11 / 0) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.58) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /76603) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.38) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3191) soft(47168/107.24) 10 e2h5 10 g7g6 ( -154) d-full( 4) Iter( 1) nps( 38616) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.12 / 2) eHhit(0.13) PHhit(0.63) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /82406) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.51) ExEV(0.03)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2521) soft(50327/108.64) 11 d6f8 11 d6f8 ( -147) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 38715) pvL( 7) targ(0) Hhit(0.15 / 1) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.58) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /89841) pvStage(0) maxD(11) fnodes(0.39) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3160) soft(54397/107.15) 12 d8d7 12 d8d7 ( -187) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38561) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.12 / 1) eHhit(0.11) PHhit(0.62) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /96529) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.43) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2960) soft(58025/105.02) 13 f8c5 13 h7h6 ( -131) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38294) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.11 / 1) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.68) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /102354) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.41) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2121) soft(61525/104.73) 14 d7d8 14 d7g7 ( -121) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38313) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.13 / 0) eHhit(0.13) PHhit(0.60) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /109682) pvStage(0) maxD( 7) fnodes(0.32) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3359) soft(65294/103.13) 15 g5h3 15 c8d7 ( -109) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38258) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.14 / 1) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.57) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /115397) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.47) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2713) soft(68198/102.21) 16 f8d6 16 f8d6 ( -111) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38200) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.09 / 0) eHhit(0.09) PHhit(0.62) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /122499) pvStage(1) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.33) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2798) soft(72298/100.64) 17 c6b8 17 g7f7 ( -129) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 38031) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.14 / 1) eHhit(0.15) PHhit(0.67) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /127272) pvStage(1) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.54) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1694) soft(75311/100.39) 18 c6e5 18 c6e5 ( -99) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37844) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.07 / 0) eHhit(0.06) PHhit(0.70) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /132300) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.43) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2441) soft(77831/100.80) 19 b5d7 19 e8d7 ( -103) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37749) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.13 / 1) eHhit(0.13) PHhit(0.62) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /138717) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.41) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2368) soft(81802/ 99.80) 20 d7c6 20 e5d3 ( -105) d-full( 4) Iter( 1) nps( 37832) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.15 / 2) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.62) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /144583) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.49) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2306) soft(85278/ 99.65) 21 f5f4 21 g6g5 ( -128) d-full( 3) Iter( 1) nps( 37826) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.18 / 0) eHhit(0.20) PHhit(0.53) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /151819) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.35) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3001) soft(89389/ 98.12) 22 d7e8 22 g5g4 ( -89) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37677) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.17 / 0) eHhit(0.18) PHhit(0.58) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /155751) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.66) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1571) soft(91684/ 97.78) 23 d7e7 23 d6e7 ( -88) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37692) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.21 / 1) eHhit(0.23) PHhit(0.50) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /160791) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.56) ExEV(0.04)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2169) soft(94403/ 97.07) 24 a8c8 24 h6h5 ( -93) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37715) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.21 / 3) eHhit(0.23) PHhit(0.49) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /165070) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.63) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2115) soft(96436/ 96.80) 25 d7c8 25 d7c8 ( -108) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37604) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.16 / 5) eHhit(0.17) PHhit(0.54) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /170453) pvStage(0) maxD( 7) fnodes(0.62) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2511) soft(99126/ 97.27) 26 c7c5 26 h5h4 ( -49) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37582) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.17 / 0) eHhit(0.18) PHhit(0.56) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /175570) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.49) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2260) soft(101847/ 98.12) 27 d3f2 27 e7d6 ( -31) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37627) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.24 / 1) eHhit(0.25) PHhit(0.57) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /180716) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.54) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1450) soft(105328/ 98.89) 28 f7g7 28 g4g3 ( -28) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37606) pvL( 7) targ(0) Hhit(0.23 / 4) eHhit(0.23) PHhit(0.61) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /185176) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.58) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1082) soft(108470/ 99.11) 29 h4g3 29 h4g3 ( 28) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37625) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.19 / 0) eHhit(0.20) PHhit(0.59) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /190800) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.53) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2190) soft(111729/ 98.89) 30 f7d5 30 f7h5 ( -4) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37614) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.12 / 0) eHhit(0.11) PHhit(0.69) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /196817) pvStage(1) maxD( 6) fnodes(0.41) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2214) soft(115383/ 98.52) 31 c7c5 31 h5h4 ( 17) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37518) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.08 / 0) eHhit(0.07) PHhit(0.76) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /201222) pvStage(0) maxD( 7) fnodes(0.44) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1029) soft(118576/ 98.64) 32 a7a6 32 d6e7 ( -10) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37573) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.15 / 1) eHhit(0.15) PHhit(0.65) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /206253) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.55) ExEV(0.03)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1829) soft(121693/ 99.13) 33 e7d8 33 h8h7 ( -5) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37544) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.18 / 0) eHhit(0.20) PHhit(0.63) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /210643) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.65) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1515) soft(124512/ 99.51) 34 c7c6 34 a7a6 ( 22) d-full( 3) Iter( 2) nps( 37511) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.16 / 0) eHhit(0.17) PHhit(0.58) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /214734) pvStage(0) maxD( 7) fnodes(0.53) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1499) soft(126999/100.56) 35 h7h5 35 d3b2 ( -85) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37648) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.32 / 0) eHhit(0.36) PHhit(0.54) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /218002) pvStage(1) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.74) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1101) soft(129030/102.92) 36 a8a7 36 b2a4 ( -109) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37676) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.10 / 0) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.65) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /223416) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.40) ExEV(0.10)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1975) soft(132387/102.99) 37 e7c5 37 h4g5 ( -135) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 37752) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.27 / 0) eHhit(0.27) PHhit(0.59) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /227864) pvStage(2) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.62) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 1517) soft(135060/104.40) 38 g6e7 38 h7e7 ( -135) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 37789) pvL( 0) targ(0) Hhit(0.10 / 0) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.65) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /233276) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.54) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2320) soft(137920/104.30) 39 e7d7 39 e7e8 ( -115) d-full( 4) Iter( 1) nps( 37784) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.28 / 0) eHhit(0.30) PHhit(0.59) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /234544) pvStage(0) maxD( 8) fnodes(0.73) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.01) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 302) soft(138841/105.73) 40 e4e3 40 g5g6 ( -115) d-full( 2) Iter( 0) nps( 37785) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.50 / 0) eHhit(0.00) PHhit(0.00) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /234544) pvStage(0) maxD( 0) fnodes(1.00) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 0) soft(138841/105.73) 41 a4b6 41 e8g8 ( -201) d-full( 4) Iter( 4) nps( 37930) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.10 / 2) eHhit(0.11) PHhit(0.63) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /245647) pvStage(0) maxD(12) fnodes(0.35) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3950) soft(145654/109.66) 42 a4c5 42 a4b6 ( -278) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 38164) pvL( 7) targ(0) Hhit(0.16 / 1) eHhit(0.18) PHhit(0.61) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /255827) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.42) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3298) soft(152133/116.68) 43 b6c4 43 g6e6 ( -255) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 38260) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.10 / 1) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.68) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /265128) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.40) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2781) soft(158306/120.34) 44 g8g5 44 b6c4 ( -237) d-full( 4) Iter( 1) nps( 38346) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.06 / 0) eHhit(0.06) PHhit(0.66) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /276296) pvStage(0) maxD(10) fnodes(0.13) ExEV(0.03)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3403) soft(165757/123.49) 45 a8a7 45 g8f8 ( -265) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 38498) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.10 / 1) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.67) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /287158) pvStage(2) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.25) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3631) soft(172590/127.45) 46 d5c5 46 c8b8 ( -357) d-full( 3) Iter( 1) nps( 38725) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.08 / 0) eHhit(0.08) PHhit(0.67) draw(0) fmFH(0.92 /297365) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.14) ExEV(0.07)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2896) soft(179541/127.89) 47 b8c8 47 c4e3 ( -534) d-full( 4) Iter( 4) nps( 38835) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.11 / 0) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.63) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /306903) pvStage(2) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.27) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3179) soft(185553/129.42) 48 b7b5 48 e3g2 ( -534) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 39020) pvL( 0) targ(0) Hhit(0.07 / 3) eHhit(0.06) PHhit(0.65) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /316352) pvStage(0) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.11) ExEV(0.06)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3184) soft(191412/131.37) 49 b8c7 49 b8a7 ( -496) d-full( 3) Iter( 3) nps( 39251) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.11 / 0) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.65) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /325121) pvStage(2) maxD( 9) fnodes(0.28) ExEV(0.06)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2746) soft(196932/133.58) 50 f4e3 50 a7b8 ( -933) d-full( 5) Iter( 4) nps( 39423) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.11 / 0) eHhit(0.11) PHhit(0.62) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /332404) pvStage(0) maxD(11) fnodes(0.23) ExEV(0.05)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 2384) soft(201553/134.98) 51 h3g3 51 f5f4 ( -966) d-full( 5) Iter( 2) nps( 39816) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.14 / 2) eHhit(0.15) PHhit(0.54) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /344435) pvStage(2) maxD(12) fnodes(0.24) ExEV(0.09)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 4356) soft(208371/140.30) 52 e3f4 52 f8f4 (-1001) d-full( 4) Iter( 2) nps( 40076) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.12 / 13) eHhit(0.10) PHhit(0.56) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /355350) pvStage(1) maxD(10) fnodes(0.24) ExEV(0.01)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3757) soft(214704/144.20) 53 e6h6 53 b8a7 (-1020) d-full( 4) Iter( 1) nps( 40576) pvL( 4) targ(0) Hhit(0.18 / 4) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.47) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /367686) pvStage(2) maxD(11) fnodes(0.42) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 5737) soft(220588/149.29) 54 f4e3 54 a7b8 (-1047) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 40973) pvL( 5) targ(0) Hhit(0.19 / 20) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.50) draw(0) fmFH(0.91 /378870) pvStage(4) maxD(11) fnodes(0.34) ExEV(0.04)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 4604) soft(226124/153.08) 55 c7g7 55 e6c8 (-1317) d-full( 4) Iter( 3) nps( 41309) pvL( 7) targ(0) Hhit(0.14 / 7) eHhit(0.13) PHhit(0.54) draw(0) fmFH(0.90 /389360) pvStage(1) maxD(11) fnodes(0.32) ExEV(0.02)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 3761) soft(231761/158.12) 56 e3b6 56 a8a7 (-7992) d-full( 2) Iter( 1) nps( 41292) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.17 / 0) eHhit(0.16) PHhit(0.49) draw(0) fmFH(0.90 /389813) pvStage(1) maxD( 6) fnodes(0.33) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 157) soft(231983/158.32) 57 d1d8 57 a7a8 (-7992) d-full( 0) Iter( 1) nps( 41335) pvL( 3) targ(0) Hhit(0.00 / 0) eHhit(0.00) PHhit(0.00) draw(0) fmFH(0.90 /389813) pvStage(1) maxD( 0) fnodes(0.33) ExEV(0.00)qExt(0.00) Prune(M 0/FS 0/QS 0) soft(231983/158.32) 58 g7b7 1-0
This page took 0.01 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.