Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Why should we help ? (was How to compile Fruit 2.1)

Author: Daniel Mehrmannn

Date: 07:34:27 06/22/05

Go up one level in this thread


On June 22, 2005 at 09:38:54, milix wrote:

>On June 22, 2005 at 09:05:32, Daniel Mehrmannn wrote:
>
>>On June 22, 2005 at 07:36:50, Andrey Popov wrote:
>>
>>>>There is really no reason why you should compile fruit.
>>>There are many things that somebody wants to change and experiment with. Only
>>>some of them are tunable via UCI options. I also wonder which of five novations
>>>in 2.1 after 2.0 is responsible for such huge improvement. I want to turn off
>>>them one by one and compare. There are no options in Fruit 2.1 to do it.
>>>>
>>>>All other things/reasons looks not so happy for me.
>>>I suspect you think about yet another clone ;)
>>>I think nobody who reads CCC will produce new clones,
>>>because there is already no fun (he will not be the first guy who made a clone)
>>>and there are no chances to hide it.
>>
>>Thats a little bit more complicated. If the users see that we're helping each
>>user  may more and more users starting request. You really don't know the
>>reasons of each user why they are want this. You can't control this too and may
>>become more problems. Clones are one point yes, but the list is long.
>>
>>So we need a general hard line to handle it fair for all. Otherwise a user could
>>say "You helped Mr. X, why not me ?" And so on.
>>
>>So my opinion is all should get the same support, here specialy no support.
>>
>>daniel
>
>This is totally against the reason Fruit released source code. If someone is
>prohibited to try his own ideas what is the point of releasing source code of
>chess engines?
>
>

This support of such users has nothing to do with GPL.
Basicly i have no problem if someone try out own ideas.

As a condition you should understand chessprograming and at least c/c++.
If this fails may we have playing kids and nothing more.

Sorry for these hard words ! My english is not so good as i could explain it
better.

Of course this is no personal attack to any CCC member !

greetings
Daniel








This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.