Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: About releasing engine source code

Author: William Bryant

Date: 17:20:58 02/15/99

Go up one level in this thread


On February 15, 1999 at 04:43:47, RĂ©mi Coulom wrote:

>It is a long time since I have considered releasing the source code of The Crazy
>Bishop since I think that it would be an excellent opportunity to share ideas
>with other programmers. However, the recent Bionic scandal and the older Gunda
>case show that doing so could cause problems. I would like to publish it anyway,
>since most tournament organizers are now aware of this problem and include
>necessary rules to avoid double entries. Anyway, if anyone here thinks that I
>should not publish the source code of TCB, I would like to hear from him(her)
>before I take this irreversible and possibly harmful decision.
>
>Remi


As a absolute beginner in chess programming, source code examples are absolutely
required to get a good comprehension of the basic functions of this field of
programming.  Only by reading, changing, and seeing the effects can one fully
understand many of these concepts.

The issue at hand is the author having any degree of control of the source.

If, and I hope it never comes to this, anyone has any doubts about releasing the
source code to their project because of worries about unauthorized
'exploitation' of their work, then consider a middle ground.

Consider requiring uses to register before downloading.  That guarentee's that
the user actively agree to a license and that this is one file.  Even a nominal
fee could be required.

I all projects I have done as a hobby, I have always started with source code
and always been gratefull to the original author.  This invaluable resource
cannot just go away without a significant negative impact on the future of this
field.
What keeps this from being a 'good old boys club' is the easy availability of
help and advice and I encourage everyone to oppenly and honestly support it.

It works for gnu, It can work here.  (Yes GNU has gone to court to defend this
positon, unfortunaltely)

From a complete beginner's standpoint.
My $0.02

William
wbryant@ix.netcom.com



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.