Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Hydra's Limit Of A Ten Move Per Line Opening Book

Author: Dan Honeycutt

Date: 14:02:25 06/24/05

Go up one level in this thread


On June 24, 2005 at 16:19:08, William H Rogers wrote:

>I think people have to ask how many moves are considered opening moves? How deep
>into the game before it becomes mid-game or end-game.  I have posted this once
>before by quoting an example of a tournement held in early 2004 when one program
>checkmated another without ever leaving its 'opening book'. In my opinion that
>is not a chess engine but a massive book or game recreator.
>I would like to see the American Chess Federation or some other main body set
>some ground rules on how deep opening books can go. I think that 10 moves should
>be enough but apparantely not all chess engine makers agree.
>The ideal proposed chess tournement should require all engines to play on
>identiacl equipment with the same depth of opening books and in this case only
>10 moves deep.
>Once and for all if this kind of tournement is done the the actual strength will
>be known. What good does it do us, the would be users if the program is written
>to play on 10 or 20 processor (multi process) at the same time or maybe we
>should allow the use of Crays once again.
>I have been making this assertion for over 10 years now but it seems that no one
>either hears me or likes my ideas.
>Bill

Hi Bill

There is nothing wrong with building a car designed to run in the Soap Box
Derby.  There is also nothing wrong with designing one to run on the Bonneville
Salt Flats.

Best
Dan H.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.