Author: Peter Kasinski
Date: 15:52:57 10/18/05
- Match of 24 games
- Fruit 2.2: FX-55 2.6 GHz; 512 Mb hash
- Deep Shredder 9.02 x64: Athlon 64 X2 4600+ 2.4GHz Dual Core; 1408Mb hash
- Shredder GUI, each engine using its own book
- Shredder with 3,4,5 and 138Gb of 6-man tablebases
- Time Control: 40 in 120, 20 in 60, rest in 30
Game 22: draw
Game 23: draw
Shredder wins the match 12.5 - 10.5 (+5 -3 =15)
12345678901234567890123
Deep Shredder 9.02 x64 0½½½½½1½0½½11½0½½½11½½½ 12.5/23
Fruit 2.2 1½½½½½0½1½½00½1½½½00½½½ 10.5/23
This was my first look at Fruit and I am impressed. This is good result against
a formidable opponent (64-bit Shredder running on roughly twice the hardware);
in fact the suggested 30-point rating difference seems to be less than the
hardware disadvantage might have indicated.
Fruit was solid in all phases of the game, one weakness (IMHO) showed on the
white side of a classical sicilian setup; being out of book on move 10 in such
thoroughly analyzed positions will tend to hurt.
On the other hand, Fruit's play in closed openings (e.g. English) was fine even
in the early out-of-book situations.
Endgames were good enough to make the huge set of Shredder's tablebases seem ir
irrelevant. Congratulations to Fabien and looking forward to future releases!
Regards,
PK
PS. On to a match against Deep Junior 9, conditions same as above.
[Event "m1"]
[Site "Toronto"]
[Date "2005.10.17"]
[Round "22"]
[White "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
[Black "Fruit 2.2"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "E05"]
[PlyCount "108"]
[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
[EventType "match"]
[EventRounds "24"]
[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nf3 d5 4. g3 Be7 5. Bg2 O-O 6. O-O dxc4 7. Qc2 a6 8. a4
Bd7 9. Qxc4 Bc6 10. Bg5 Bd5 11. Qc2 Be4 12. Qc1 h6 13. Bf4 Nc6 14. Rd1 Nd5 15.
Nc3 Nxc3 16. bxc3 Na5 17. Nd2 Bxg2 18. Kxg2 Bd6 19. Be3 f5 20. Qc2 Qe8 21. c4
f4 22. gxf4 Bxf4 23. Nf3 c5 24. Qc3 Qg6+ 25. Kh1 Qe4 26. dxc5 e5 27. Rd7 Bxe3
28. Qxe3 Qxe3 29. fxe3 Rad8 30. Nxe5 Rxd7 31. Nxd7 Rf2 32. Rb1 Rxe2 33. Rb6 h5
34. Kg1 Rc2 35. c6 Nxc6 36. Rxb7 Rxc4 37. Rb6 a5 38. Ra6 Rc2 39. Rb6 h4 40. h3
g6 41. Rb7 Rc4 42. Rb6 Rc2 43. Kf1 Kh7 44. Ke1 Nb4 45. Rb7 Kg8 46. Nf6+ Kf8 47.
Rd7 Rh2 48. Kf1 Rxh3 49. Kf2 Rh2+ 50. Kf3 Rc2 51. Nh7+ Kg8 52. Nf6+ Kf8 53.
Nh7+ Kg8 54. Nf6+ Kf8 1/2-1/2
[Event "m1"]
[Site "Toronto"]
[Date "2005.10.17"]
[Round "23"]
[White "Fruit 2.2"]
[Black "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D58"]
[PlyCount "176"]
[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
[EventType "match"]
[EventRounds "24"]
[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. Nf3 e6 3. c4 d5 4. Nc3 Be7 5. Bg5 h6 6. Bh4 O-O 7. e3 b6 8. Be2
Bb7 9. Rc1 c5 10. cxd5 Nxd5 11. Bxe7 Qxe7 12. dxc5 Qxc5 13. O-O Qb4 14. Nxd5
Bxd5 15. Qd4 Qxd4 16. Nxd4 Nd7 17. Rc7 Nf6 18. a3 Rfc8 19. Rfc1 Rxc7 20. Rxc7
Ne8 21. Rc1 Kf8 22. f4 Nd6 23. Kf2 Rc8 24. Rxc8+ Nxc8 25. Bf3 Nd6 26. Bxd5 exd5
27. Ke2 Nc4 28. Nb5 Nxb2 29. Nxa7 Ke8 30. Nb5 Kd7 31. Kd2 h5 32. Kc3 Na4+ 33.
Kc2 Nc5 34. Nd4 Ne4 35. Kd3 Nc5+ 36. Kd2 Ne4+ 37. Kc2 Nd6 38. Kd3 Nc4 39. e4
Nxa3 40. exd5 g6 41. Nf3 Kd6 42. Ne5 Kxd5 43. Nxf7 Ke6 44. Ne5 Kf5 45. Kc3 g5
46. Nd7 Kxf4 47. Nxb6 Ke4 48. Nd7 h4 49. Nf6+ Ke5 50. Ng4+ Kf4 51. Nf6 Nb5+ 52.
Kc4 Nc7 53. Kd3 Na6 54. Nd5+ Ke5 55. Kc4 Nb8 56. Nb4 Ke4 57. Nd3 Nc6 58. Nc5+
Ke5 59. Nd3+ Ke4 60. Nc5+ Ke5 61. Nd3+ Kf5 62. Kd5 Na7 63. Kc5 Ke4 64. Kc4 Nc8
65. Nc5+ Kf5 66. Kd4 Nd6 67. h3 g4 68. hxg4+ Kxg4 69. Nd3 Nf7 70. Kd5 Kf5 71.
Kd4 Kg4 72. Ke3 Kg3 73. Nf4 Ne5 74. Ke4 Nf7 75. Kf5 Nd6+ 76. Ke5 Nc4+ 77. Ke4
Nd6+ 78. Ke5 Nc4+ 79. Ke4 Kf2 80. Kd4 Nd2 81. Kd5 Nf1 82. Kd4 Kg3 83. Ke4 Kf2
84. Kf5 Ne3+ 85. Kg5 Nxg2 86. Kg4 Ne3+ 87. Kxh4 Ke1 88. Nd3+ Kd1 1/2-1/2
same with merged annotations by both engines:
[Event "m1"]
[Site "Toronto"]
[Date "2005.10.17"]
[Round "22"]
[White "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
[Black "Fruit 2.2"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "E05"]
[PlyCount "108"]
[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
[EventType "match"]
[EventRounds "24"]
[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nf3 d5 4. g3 Be7 5. Bg2 O-O 6. O-O dxc4 7. Qc2 a6 8. a4
Bd7 9. Qxc4 Bc6 10. Bg5 Bd5 11. Qc2 Be4 12. Qc1 h6 13. Bf4 Nc6 14. Rd1 {
5:52; d20; -0.11; Nd5} Nd5 {4:44; d17; +0.01; Nc3} 15. Nc3 {
0:39; d21; -0.11; Nxc3} Nxc3 {3:17; d17; =0.00; bc} 16. bxc3 {
3:20; d22; -0.08; Na5} Na5 {0:06; d17; -0.03; Nd2} 17. Nd2 {
4:57; d21; -0.10; Bxg2} Bxg2 {0:00; d19; =0.00; Kxg2} 18. Kxg2 {
4:52; d22; -0.08; Bd6} Bd6 {0:00; d19; =0.00; Be3} 19. Be3 {
10:50; d21; -0.08; c6} f5 {0:00; d18; =0.00; Kh1} 20. Qc2 {
7:14; d20; +0.05; Qd7} Qe8 {8:05; d18; =0.00; Kh1} 21. c4 {6:43; d19; +0.17; b5
} f4 {6:35; d17; -0.03; gf} 22. gxf4 {6:29; d19; -0.04; Bxf4} Bxf4 {
1:16; d17; -0.07; Nf3} 23. Nf3 {3:12; d19; -0.03; Bxe3} c5 {
1:21; d17; +0.12; Qc3} 24. Qc3 {3:41; d18; +0.17; cd} Qg6+ {
4:32; d17; =0.00; Kh1} 25. Kh1 {3:52; d20; +0.32; Qe4} Qe4 {
3:58; d19; =0.00; Bxf4} 26. dxc5 {0:36; d20; +0.36; Bxe3} e5 {
6:09; d18; =0.00; Bxf4} 27. Rd7 {13:56; d20; +0.11; Bxe3} Bxe3 {
5:02; d18; =0.00; Rg1} 28. Qxe3 {0:00; d21; +0.42; Qxe3} Qxe3 {
7:56; d21; +0.03; fe} 29. fxe3 {0:00; d25; +0.58; Rae8} Rad8 {
8:41; d22; +0.05; Nxe5} 30. Nxe5 {4:42; d24; +0.65; Rxd7} Rxd7 {
2:22; d22; =0.00; Nxd7} 31. Nxd7 {0:00; d24; +0.46; Rf7} Rf2 {
9:15; d23; +0.05; Re1} 32. Rb1 {8:12; d24; +0.35; Rxe2} Rxe2 {
4:38; d21; +0.08; Rb6} 33. Rb6 {0:00; d24; +0.16; Rc2} h5 {7:25; d21; +0.21; c6
} 34. Kg1 {4:35; d22; +0.19; Rc2} Rc2 {7:08; d21; +0.10; Ne5} 35. c6 {
1:37; d24; +0.15; Nxc6} Nxc6 {5:31; d22; +0.10; Rxb7} 36. Rxb7 {
0:00; d24; +0.01; Rxc4} Rxc4 {3:39; d21; +0.09; Rc7} 37. Rb6 {
0:32; d23; +0.02; a5} a5 {3:52; d20; +0.05; Kf2} 38. Ra6 {1:23; d23; +0.03; g5}
Rc2 {5:25; d21; =0.00; h4} 39. Rb6 {6:31; d23; =0.00; g6} h4 {
4:44; d20; =0.00; h3} 40. h3 {5:32; d24; =0.00; g6} g6 {0:00; d22; =0.00; Kf1}
41. Rb7 {1:05; d22; =0.00; Rc4} Rc4 {4:00; d21; =0.00; Rb6} 42. Rb6 {
0:37; d23; =0.00; Rc2} Rc2 {4:11; d23; =0.00; Kf1} 43. Kf1 {
1:40; d25; =0.00; Kg7} Kh7 {3:20; d21; =0.00; Ke1} 44. Ke1 {
4:56; d23; +0.04; Nb4} Nb4 {0:00; d22; =0.00; Ne5} 45. Rb7 {
3:49; d22; +0.03; Kg8} Kg8 {2:40; d20; =0.00; Ne5} 46. Nf6+ {
1:48; d22; +0.03; Kf8} Kf8 {2:27; d20; =0.00; Rd7} 47. Rd7 {
2:18; d22; +0.02; Rh2} Rh2 {1:43; d23; =0.00; Kd1} 48. Kf1 {
5:21; d21; +0.02; Nc2} Rxh3 {3:01; d25; =0.00; Nh7} 49. Kf2 {
5:42; d23; +0.02; Rg3} Rh2+ {3:18; d24; =0.00; Kf3} 50. Kf3 {
3:46; d24; +0.01; Nc6} Rc2 {0:00; d24; =0.00; Nh7} 51. Nh7+ {
4:01; d23; +0.01; Ke8} Kg8 {0:25; d25; =0.00; Nf6} 52. Nf6+ {
3:40; d23; =0.00; Kf8} Kf8 {0:00; d63; =0.00; Nh7} 53. Nh7+ {
4:01; d24; =0.00; Kg8} Kg8 {5:50; d46; =0.00; Nf6} 54. Nf6+ {
0:18; d26; =0.00; Kf8} Kf8 {0:00; d63; =0.00} 1/2-1/2
[Event "m1"]
[Site "Toronto"]
[Date "2005.10.17"]
[Round "23"]
[White "Fruit 2.2"]
[Black "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D58"]
[PlyCount "176"]
[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
[EventType "match"]
[EventRounds "24"]
[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. Nf3 e6 3. c4 d5 4. Nc3 Be7 5. Bg5 h6 6. Bh4 O-O 7. e3 b6 8. Be2
Bb7 9. Rc1 c5 10. cxd5 {5:26; d17; +0.31; Nxd5} Nxd5 {0:00; d21; -0.28; Bxe7}
11. Bxe7 {3:23; d18; +0.29; Qxe7} Qxe7 {1:19; d22; -0.28; dc} 12. dxc5 {
2:16; d18; +0.30; bc} Qxc5 13. O-O {5:53; d18; +0.40; Qb4} Qb4 14. Nxd5 {
6:24; d18; +0.33; Qd2} Bxd5 {0:16; d17; -0.51; Qd4} 15. Qd4 {
2:48; d18; +0.33; Qxd4} Qxd4 {0:00; d20; -0.49; Nxd4} 16. Nxd4 {
4:52; d18; +0.36; Nd7} Nd7 {6:34; d23; -0.50; a3} 17. Rc7 {
0:00; d19; +0.31; Rfd8} Nf6 {7:49; d22; -0.33; a3} 18. a3 {
7:08; d19; +0.15; Rfd8} Rfc8 {0:00; d23; -0.34; Rfc1} 19. Rfc1 {
4:12; d21; +0.26; Rxc7} Rxc7 {0:00; d23; -0.32; Rxc7} 20. Rxc7 {
4:36; d20; +0.21; Ne8} Ne8 {2:02; d22; -0.31; Rc3} 21. Rc1 {
2:53; d20; +0.19; Rd8} Kf8 {5:08; d21; -0.31; f4} 22. f4 {9:21; d19; +0.14; Nd6
} Nd6 {0:00; d23; -0.32; Kf2} 23. Kf2 {5:12; d19; +0.12; Rc8} Rc8 {
0:57; d24; -0.25; Rxc8} 24. Rxc8+ {2:21; d22; +0.10; Nxc8} Nxc8 {
0:00; d27; -0.25; Bf3} 25. Bf3 {3:14; d23; +0.10; Nd6} Nd6 {
4:47; d27; -0.17; Bxd5} 26. Bxd5 {0:15; d23; +0.10; ed} exd5 {
8:30; d28; -0.23; b3} 27. Ke2 {0:00; d24; +0.10; Ke8} Nc4 {
5:07; d29; -0.01; Nb5} 28. Nb5 {3:00; d24; +0.20; Nxb2} Nxb2 {
3:53; d30; -0.04; Nxa7} 29. Nxa7 {0:00; d25; +0.06; Ke8} Ke8 {
18:14; d30; -0.33; Nb5} 30. Nb5 {0:00; d27; +0.04; Kd7} Kd7 {
5:26; d29; -0.16; g4} 31. Kd2 {1:38; d26; +0.06; h5} h5 {8:33; d28; -0.12; Kc3}
32. Kc3 {3:06; d26; +0.02; Nc4} Na4+ {1:51; d28; -0.13; Kb3} 33. Kc2 {
6:23; d26; +0.04; Nc5} Nc5 {8:34; d27; -0.07; Na7} 34. Nd4 {
0:00; d28; +0.04; Ne4} Ne4 {3:12; d26; -0.06; g3} 35. Kd3 {
6:20; d27; +0.04; Nc5} Nc5+ {2:51; d27; =0.00; Kc3} 36. Kd2 {
5:59; d27; +0.04; Ke7} Ne4+ {3:14; d26; =0.00; Kd3} 37. Kc2 {
5:25; d25; +0.04; Ke7} Nd6 {2:48; d26; -0.01; Kd3} 38. Kd3 {
6:38; d25; +0.03; g6} Nc4 {0:08; d30; +0.07; e4} 39. e4 {7:28; d25; +0.03; Nxa3
} Nxa3 {0:19; d29; +0.05; ed} 40. exd5 {2:29; d25; +0.01; g6} g6 {
3:56; d30; +0.03; f5} 41. Nf3 {0:00; d27; =0.00; Kd6} Kd6 {
6:06; d29; +0.08; Ne5} 42. Ne5 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Kxd5} Kxd5 {
6:20; d30; +0.11; Nxf7} 43. Nxf7 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Ke6} Ke6 {
5:11; d30; +0.05; Ng5} 44. Ne5 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Kf5} Kf5 {
0:50; d26; +0.01; g3} 45. Kc3 {2:46; d26; =0.00; g5} g5 {6:15; d28; +0.18; Nd7}
46. Nd7 {0:00; d28; =0.00; Kxf4} Kxf4 {4:30; d28; +0.10; Nxb6} 47. Nxb6 {
0:00; d29; =0.00; Nb5} Ke4 {4:37; d29; +0.07; Nd7} 48. Nd7 {
4:14; d29; =0.00; h4} h4 {0:00; d29; +0.08; Nf6} 49. Nf6+ {
5:17; d31; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:00; d29; +0.07; Nd7} 50. Ng4+ {
6:30; d32; =0.00; Ke4} Kf4 {3:11; d30; +0.05; Nf2} 51. Nf6 {
3:18; d31; =0.00; Nb5} Nb5+ {5:43; d28; +0.01; Kd3} 52. Kc4 {
0:28; d31; =0.00; Ke5} Nc7 {0:49; d26; +0.06; Kd3} 53. Kd3 {
3:49; d31; =0.00; Kf5} Na6 {3:19; d30; +0.05; Nd5} 54. Nd5+ {
4:53; d32; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:00; d32; +0.02; Ne7} 55. Kc4 {
7:32; d34; =0.00; Nb8} Nb8 {4:43; d30; +0.05; Nc3} 56. Nb4 {
0:04; d32; =0.00; Nd7} Ke4 {2:47; d29; +0.06; Nd3} 57. Nd3 {
8:25; d34; =0.00; Nd7} Nc6 {0:00; d31; +0.09; Nc5} 58. Nc5+ {
4:50; d30; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {5:01; d30; +0.06; Nd3} 59. Nd3+ {
0:02; d33; =0.00; Kf5} Ke4 {0:43; d28; +0.06; Nc5} 60. Nc5+ {
4:37; d35; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:17; d31; +0.05; Nd3} 61. Nd3+ {
2:32; d34; =0.00; Kf5} Kf5 {0:00; d30; +0.05; Nf2} 62. Kd5 {
0:49; d30; =0.00; Ne7} Na7 {0:51; d26; +0.04; Nf2} 63. Kc5 {
1:15; d30; =0.00; Nc8} Ke4 {0:13; d17; +0.04; Nf2} 64. Kc4 {
0:57; d28; =0.00; Nc6} Nc8 {1:01; d26; +0.06; Nc5} 65. Nc5+ {
0:49; d26; =0.00; Kf4} Kf5 {0:25; d26; +0.06; Kd4} 66. Kd4 {
0:52; d30; =0.00; Ne7} Nd6 {0:03; d23; +0.06; Kd5} 67. h3 {
0:48; d28; =0.00; Kf4} g4 {1:03; d26; +0.02; Nd3} 68. hxg4+ {
0:43; d26; =0.00; Kxg4} Kxg4 {0:02; d15; +0.06; Nd3} 69. Nd3 {
0:42; d30; =0.00; Nc8} Nf7 {0:15; d30; +0.01; Ke4} 70. Kd5 {
0:53; d33; =0.00; Kg3} Kf5 {0:47; d30; +0.01; Kd4} 71. Kd4 {
1:12; d32; =0.00; Ne5} Kg4 {0:00; d32; +0.01; Ke3} 72. Ke3 {
0:48; d33; =0.00; Ne5} Kg3 {0:09; d31; +0.01; Ne1} 73. Nf4 {
0:43; d33; =0.00; h3} Ne5 {0:41; d31; +0.01; Ke4} 74. Ke4 {
0:57; d31; =0.00; Nc6} Nf7 {0:00; d32; +0.01; Nh5} 75. Kf5 {
0:47; d33; =0.00; Nd6} Nd6+ {0:10; d31; +0.01; Kg5} 76. Ke5 {
0:23; d30; =0.00; Nc4} Nc4+ {1:43; d30; +0.01; Kf5} 77. Ke4 {
0:00; d33; =0.00; Nd6} Nd6+ {0:40; d30; +0.01; Ke5} 78. Ke5 {
0:00; d41; =0.00; Nc4} Nc4+ {0:11; d29; +0.01; Kf5} 79. Ke4 {
0:49; d44; =0.00; Kf2} Kf2 {0:13; d27; +0.01; Kd4} 80. Kd4 {
0:28; d29; =0.00; Ne3} Nd2 {0:20; d28; +0.01; Kd5} 81. Kd5 {
0:58; d30; =0.00; Kg3} Nf1 {0:55; d35; +0.01; Ng6} 82. Kd4 {
0:28; d26; =0.00; Nd2} Kg3 {0:56; d35; +0.01; Ke4} 83. Ke4 {
0:41; d33; =0.00; Nd2} Kf2 {0:24; d34; +0.01; Ng6} 84. Kf5 {
0:53; d28; =0.00; Ne3} Ne3+ {0:38; d69; +0.01; Kg5} 85. Kg5 {
0:00; d33; =0.00; Nxg2} Nxg2 {0:00; d99; +0.01; Nxg2} 86. Kg4 {
0:22; d37; =0.00; Nxf4} Ne3+ {0:02; d21; =0.00; Kxh4} 87. Kxh4 {
0:23; d43; =0.00; Kf3} Ke1 {0:00; d4; =0.00; Ne6} 88. Nd3+ {
0:24; d49; =0.00; Ke2} Kd1 {0:00; d4; =0.00} 1/2-1/2
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.