Author: Vincent Lejeune
Date: 00:44:06 10/19/05
Go up one level in this thread
Thanks for this very interresting match : long time control and fast hardware !
On October 18, 2005 at 18:52:57, Peter Kasinski wrote:
>- Match of 24 games
>- Fruit 2.2: FX-55 2.6 GHz; 512 Mb hash
>- Deep Shredder 9.02 x64: Athlon 64 X2 4600+ 2.4GHz Dual Core; 1408Mb hash
>- Shredder GUI, each engine using its own book
>- Shredder with 3,4,5 and 138Gb of 6-man tablebases
>- Time Control: 40 in 120, 20 in 60, rest in 30
>
>Game 22: draw
>Game 23: draw
>
>Shredder wins the match 12.5 - 10.5 (+5 -3 =15)
>
> 12345678901234567890123
>Deep Shredder 9.02 x64 0½½½½½1½0½½11½0½½½11½½½ 12.5/23
>Fruit 2.2 1½½½½½0½1½½00½1½½½00½½½ 10.5/23
>
>This was my first look at Fruit and I am impressed. This is good result against
>a formidable opponent (64-bit Shredder running on roughly twice the hardware);
>in fact the suggested 30-point rating difference seems to be less than the
>hardware disadvantage might have indicated.
>
>Fruit was solid in all phases of the game, one weakness (IMHO) showed on the
>white side of a classical sicilian setup; being out of book on move 10 in such
>thoroughly analyzed positions will tend to hurt.
>
>On the other hand, Fruit's play in closed openings (e.g. English) was fine even
>in the early out-of-book situations.
>
>Endgames were good enough to make the huge set of Shredder's tablebases seem ir
>irrelevant. Congratulations to Fabien and looking forward to future releases!
>
>Regards,
>PK
>
>PS. On to a match against Deep Junior 9, conditions same as above.
>
>
>[Event "m1"]
>[Site "Toronto"]
>[Date "2005.10.17"]
>[Round "22"]
>[White "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
>[Black "Fruit 2.2"]
>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>[ECO "E05"]
>[PlyCount "108"]
>[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
>[EventType "match"]
>[EventRounds "24"]
>[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
>
>1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nf3 d5 4. g3 Be7 5. Bg2 O-O 6. O-O dxc4 7. Qc2 a6 8. a4
>Bd7 9. Qxc4 Bc6 10. Bg5 Bd5 11. Qc2 Be4 12. Qc1 h6 13. Bf4 Nc6 14. Rd1 Nd5 15.
>Nc3 Nxc3 16. bxc3 Na5 17. Nd2 Bxg2 18. Kxg2 Bd6 19. Be3 f5 20. Qc2 Qe8 21. c4
>f4 22. gxf4 Bxf4 23. Nf3 c5 24. Qc3 Qg6+ 25. Kh1 Qe4 26. dxc5 e5 27. Rd7 Bxe3
>28. Qxe3 Qxe3 29. fxe3 Rad8 30. Nxe5 Rxd7 31. Nxd7 Rf2 32. Rb1 Rxe2 33. Rb6 h5
>34. Kg1 Rc2 35. c6 Nxc6 36. Rxb7 Rxc4 37. Rb6 a5 38. Ra6 Rc2 39. Rb6 h4 40. h3
>g6 41. Rb7 Rc4 42. Rb6 Rc2 43. Kf1 Kh7 44. Ke1 Nb4 45. Rb7 Kg8 46. Nf6+ Kf8 47.
>Rd7 Rh2 48. Kf1 Rxh3 49. Kf2 Rh2+ 50. Kf3 Rc2 51. Nh7+ Kg8 52. Nf6+ Kf8 53.
>Nh7+ Kg8 54. Nf6+ Kf8 1/2-1/2
>
>
>[Event "m1"]
>[Site "Toronto"]
>[Date "2005.10.17"]
>[Round "23"]
>[White "Fruit 2.2"]
>[Black "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>[ECO "D58"]
>[PlyCount "176"]
>[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
>[EventType "match"]
>[EventRounds "24"]
>[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
>
>1. d4 Nf6 2. Nf3 e6 3. c4 d5 4. Nc3 Be7 5. Bg5 h6 6. Bh4 O-O 7. e3 b6 8. Be2
>Bb7 9. Rc1 c5 10. cxd5 Nxd5 11. Bxe7 Qxe7 12. dxc5 Qxc5 13. O-O Qb4 14. Nxd5
>Bxd5 15. Qd4 Qxd4 16. Nxd4 Nd7 17. Rc7 Nf6 18. a3 Rfc8 19. Rfc1 Rxc7 20. Rxc7
>Ne8 21. Rc1 Kf8 22. f4 Nd6 23. Kf2 Rc8 24. Rxc8+ Nxc8 25. Bf3 Nd6 26. Bxd5 exd5
>27. Ke2 Nc4 28. Nb5 Nxb2 29. Nxa7 Ke8 30. Nb5 Kd7 31. Kd2 h5 32. Kc3 Na4+ 33.
>Kc2 Nc5 34. Nd4 Ne4 35. Kd3 Nc5+ 36. Kd2 Ne4+ 37. Kc2 Nd6 38. Kd3 Nc4 39. e4
>Nxa3 40. exd5 g6 41. Nf3 Kd6 42. Ne5 Kxd5 43. Nxf7 Ke6 44. Ne5 Kf5 45. Kc3 g5
>46. Nd7 Kxf4 47. Nxb6 Ke4 48. Nd7 h4 49. Nf6+ Ke5 50. Ng4+ Kf4 51. Nf6 Nb5+ 52.
>Kc4 Nc7 53. Kd3 Na6 54. Nd5+ Ke5 55. Kc4 Nb8 56. Nb4 Ke4 57. Nd3 Nc6 58. Nc5+
>Ke5 59. Nd3+ Ke4 60. Nc5+ Ke5 61. Nd3+ Kf5 62. Kd5 Na7 63. Kc5 Ke4 64. Kc4 Nc8
>65. Nc5+ Kf5 66. Kd4 Nd6 67. h3 g4 68. hxg4+ Kxg4 69. Nd3 Nf7 70. Kd5 Kf5 71.
>Kd4 Kg4 72. Ke3 Kg3 73. Nf4 Ne5 74. Ke4 Nf7 75. Kf5 Nd6+ 76. Ke5 Nc4+ 77. Ke4
>Nd6+ 78. Ke5 Nc4+ 79. Ke4 Kf2 80. Kd4 Nd2 81. Kd5 Nf1 82. Kd4 Kg3 83. Ke4 Kf2
>84. Kf5 Ne3+ 85. Kg5 Nxg2 86. Kg4 Ne3+ 87. Kxh4 Ke1 88. Nd3+ Kd1 1/2-1/2
>
>
>same with merged annotations by both engines:
>
>
>[Event "m1"]
>[Site "Toronto"]
>[Date "2005.10.17"]
>[Round "22"]
>[White "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
>[Black "Fruit 2.2"]
>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>[ECO "E05"]
>[PlyCount "108"]
>[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
>[EventType "match"]
>[EventRounds "24"]
>[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
>
>1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nf3 d5 4. g3 Be7 5. Bg2 O-O 6. O-O dxc4 7. Qc2 a6 8. a4
>Bd7 9. Qxc4 Bc6 10. Bg5 Bd5 11. Qc2 Be4 12. Qc1 h6 13. Bf4 Nc6 14. Rd1 {
>5:52; d20; -0.11; Nd5} Nd5 {4:44; d17; +0.01; Nc3} 15. Nc3 {
>0:39; d21; -0.11; Nxc3} Nxc3 {3:17; d17; =0.00; bc} 16. bxc3 {
>3:20; d22; -0.08; Na5} Na5 {0:06; d17; -0.03; Nd2} 17. Nd2 {
>4:57; d21; -0.10; Bxg2} Bxg2 {0:00; d19; =0.00; Kxg2} 18. Kxg2 {
>4:52; d22; -0.08; Bd6} Bd6 {0:00; d19; =0.00; Be3} 19. Be3 {
>10:50; d21; -0.08; c6} f5 {0:00; d18; =0.00; Kh1} 20. Qc2 {
>7:14; d20; +0.05; Qd7} Qe8 {8:05; d18; =0.00; Kh1} 21. c4 {6:43; d19; +0.17; b5
>} f4 {6:35; d17; -0.03; gf} 22. gxf4 {6:29; d19; -0.04; Bxf4} Bxf4 {
>1:16; d17; -0.07; Nf3} 23. Nf3 {3:12; d19; -0.03; Bxe3} c5 {
>1:21; d17; +0.12; Qc3} 24. Qc3 {3:41; d18; +0.17; cd} Qg6+ {
>4:32; d17; =0.00; Kh1} 25. Kh1 {3:52; d20; +0.32; Qe4} Qe4 {
>3:58; d19; =0.00; Bxf4} 26. dxc5 {0:36; d20; +0.36; Bxe3} e5 {
>6:09; d18; =0.00; Bxf4} 27. Rd7 {13:56; d20; +0.11; Bxe3} Bxe3 {
>5:02; d18; =0.00; Rg1} 28. Qxe3 {0:00; d21; +0.42; Qxe3} Qxe3 {
>7:56; d21; +0.03; fe} 29. fxe3 {0:00; d25; +0.58; Rae8} Rad8 {
>8:41; d22; +0.05; Nxe5} 30. Nxe5 {4:42; d24; +0.65; Rxd7} Rxd7 {
>2:22; d22; =0.00; Nxd7} 31. Nxd7 {0:00; d24; +0.46; Rf7} Rf2 {
>9:15; d23; +0.05; Re1} 32. Rb1 {8:12; d24; +0.35; Rxe2} Rxe2 {
>4:38; d21; +0.08; Rb6} 33. Rb6 {0:00; d24; +0.16; Rc2} h5 {7:25; d21; +0.21; c6
>} 34. Kg1 {4:35; d22; +0.19; Rc2} Rc2 {7:08; d21; +0.10; Ne5} 35. c6 {
>1:37; d24; +0.15; Nxc6} Nxc6 {5:31; d22; +0.10; Rxb7} 36. Rxb7 {
>0:00; d24; +0.01; Rxc4} Rxc4 {3:39; d21; +0.09; Rc7} 37. Rb6 {
>0:32; d23; +0.02; a5} a5 {3:52; d20; +0.05; Kf2} 38. Ra6 {1:23; d23; +0.03; g5}
>Rc2 {5:25; d21; =0.00; h4} 39. Rb6 {6:31; d23; =0.00; g6} h4 {
>4:44; d20; =0.00; h3} 40. h3 {5:32; d24; =0.00; g6} g6 {0:00; d22; =0.00; Kf1}
>41. Rb7 {1:05; d22; =0.00; Rc4} Rc4 {4:00; d21; =0.00; Rb6} 42. Rb6 {
>0:37; d23; =0.00; Rc2} Rc2 {4:11; d23; =0.00; Kf1} 43. Kf1 {
>1:40; d25; =0.00; Kg7} Kh7 {3:20; d21; =0.00; Ke1} 44. Ke1 {
>4:56; d23; +0.04; Nb4} Nb4 {0:00; d22; =0.00; Ne5} 45. Rb7 {
>3:49; d22; +0.03; Kg8} Kg8 {2:40; d20; =0.00; Ne5} 46. Nf6+ {
>1:48; d22; +0.03; Kf8} Kf8 {2:27; d20; =0.00; Rd7} 47. Rd7 {
>2:18; d22; +0.02; Rh2} Rh2 {1:43; d23; =0.00; Kd1} 48. Kf1 {
>5:21; d21; +0.02; Nc2} Rxh3 {3:01; d25; =0.00; Nh7} 49. Kf2 {
>5:42; d23; +0.02; Rg3} Rh2+ {3:18; d24; =0.00; Kf3} 50. Kf3 {
>3:46; d24; +0.01; Nc6} Rc2 {0:00; d24; =0.00; Nh7} 51. Nh7+ {
>4:01; d23; +0.01; Ke8} Kg8 {0:25; d25; =0.00; Nf6} 52. Nf6+ {
>3:40; d23; =0.00; Kf8} Kf8 {0:00; d63; =0.00; Nh7} 53. Nh7+ {
>4:01; d24; =0.00; Kg8} Kg8 {5:50; d46; =0.00; Nf6} 54. Nf6+ {
>0:18; d26; =0.00; Kf8} Kf8 {0:00; d63; =0.00} 1/2-1/2
>
>[Event "m1"]
>[Site "Toronto"]
>[Date "2005.10.17"]
>[Round "23"]
>[White "Fruit 2.2"]
>[Black "Deep Shredder 9.02 x64"]
>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>[ECO "D58"]
>[PlyCount "176"]
>[EventDate "2005.10.17"]
>[EventType "match"]
>[EventRounds "24"]
>[SourceDate "2005.10.17"]
>
>1. d4 Nf6 2. Nf3 e6 3. c4 d5 4. Nc3 Be7 5. Bg5 h6 6. Bh4 O-O 7. e3 b6 8. Be2
>Bb7 9. Rc1 c5 10. cxd5 {5:26; d17; +0.31; Nxd5} Nxd5 {0:00; d21; -0.28; Bxe7}
>11. Bxe7 {3:23; d18; +0.29; Qxe7} Qxe7 {1:19; d22; -0.28; dc} 12. dxc5 {
>2:16; d18; +0.30; bc} Qxc5 13. O-O {5:53; d18; +0.40; Qb4} Qb4 14. Nxd5 {
>6:24; d18; +0.33; Qd2} Bxd5 {0:16; d17; -0.51; Qd4} 15. Qd4 {
>2:48; d18; +0.33; Qxd4} Qxd4 {0:00; d20; -0.49; Nxd4} 16. Nxd4 {
>4:52; d18; +0.36; Nd7} Nd7 {6:34; d23; -0.50; a3} 17. Rc7 {
>0:00; d19; +0.31; Rfd8} Nf6 {7:49; d22; -0.33; a3} 18. a3 {
>7:08; d19; +0.15; Rfd8} Rfc8 {0:00; d23; -0.34; Rfc1} 19. Rfc1 {
>4:12; d21; +0.26; Rxc7} Rxc7 {0:00; d23; -0.32; Rxc7} 20. Rxc7 {
>4:36; d20; +0.21; Ne8} Ne8 {2:02; d22; -0.31; Rc3} 21. Rc1 {
>2:53; d20; +0.19; Rd8} Kf8 {5:08; d21; -0.31; f4} 22. f4 {9:21; d19; +0.14; Nd6
>} Nd6 {0:00; d23; -0.32; Kf2} 23. Kf2 {5:12; d19; +0.12; Rc8} Rc8 {
>0:57; d24; -0.25; Rxc8} 24. Rxc8+ {2:21; d22; +0.10; Nxc8} Nxc8 {
>0:00; d27; -0.25; Bf3} 25. Bf3 {3:14; d23; +0.10; Nd6} Nd6 {
>4:47; d27; -0.17; Bxd5} 26. Bxd5 {0:15; d23; +0.10; ed} exd5 {
>8:30; d28; -0.23; b3} 27. Ke2 {0:00; d24; +0.10; Ke8} Nc4 {
>5:07; d29; -0.01; Nb5} 28. Nb5 {3:00; d24; +0.20; Nxb2} Nxb2 {
>3:53; d30; -0.04; Nxa7} 29. Nxa7 {0:00; d25; +0.06; Ke8} Ke8 {
>18:14; d30; -0.33; Nb5} 30. Nb5 {0:00; d27; +0.04; Kd7} Kd7 {
>5:26; d29; -0.16; g4} 31. Kd2 {1:38; d26; +0.06; h5} h5 {8:33; d28; -0.12; Kc3}
>32. Kc3 {3:06; d26; +0.02; Nc4} Na4+ {1:51; d28; -0.13; Kb3} 33. Kc2 {
>6:23; d26; +0.04; Nc5} Nc5 {8:34; d27; -0.07; Na7} 34. Nd4 {
>0:00; d28; +0.04; Ne4} Ne4 {3:12; d26; -0.06; g3} 35. Kd3 {
>6:20; d27; +0.04; Nc5} Nc5+ {2:51; d27; =0.00; Kc3} 36. Kd2 {
>5:59; d27; +0.04; Ke7} Ne4+ {3:14; d26; =0.00; Kd3} 37. Kc2 {
>5:25; d25; +0.04; Ke7} Nd6 {2:48; d26; -0.01; Kd3} 38. Kd3 {
>6:38; d25; +0.03; g6} Nc4 {0:08; d30; +0.07; e4} 39. e4 {7:28; d25; +0.03; Nxa3
>} Nxa3 {0:19; d29; +0.05; ed} 40. exd5 {2:29; d25; +0.01; g6} g6 {
>3:56; d30; +0.03; f5} 41. Nf3 {0:00; d27; =0.00; Kd6} Kd6 {
>6:06; d29; +0.08; Ne5} 42. Ne5 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Kxd5} Kxd5 {
>6:20; d30; +0.11; Nxf7} 43. Nxf7 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Ke6} Ke6 {
>5:11; d30; +0.05; Ng5} 44. Ne5 {0:00; d29; =0.00; Kf5} Kf5 {
>0:50; d26; +0.01; g3} 45. Kc3 {2:46; d26; =0.00; g5} g5 {6:15; d28; +0.18; Nd7}
>46. Nd7 {0:00; d28; =0.00; Kxf4} Kxf4 {4:30; d28; +0.10; Nxb6} 47. Nxb6 {
>0:00; d29; =0.00; Nb5} Ke4 {4:37; d29; +0.07; Nd7} 48. Nd7 {
>4:14; d29; =0.00; h4} h4 {0:00; d29; +0.08; Nf6} 49. Nf6+ {
>5:17; d31; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:00; d29; +0.07; Nd7} 50. Ng4+ {
>6:30; d32; =0.00; Ke4} Kf4 {3:11; d30; +0.05; Nf2} 51. Nf6 {
>3:18; d31; =0.00; Nb5} Nb5+ {5:43; d28; +0.01; Kd3} 52. Kc4 {
>0:28; d31; =0.00; Ke5} Nc7 {0:49; d26; +0.06; Kd3} 53. Kd3 {
>3:49; d31; =0.00; Kf5} Na6 {3:19; d30; +0.05; Nd5} 54. Nd5+ {
>4:53; d32; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:00; d32; +0.02; Ne7} 55. Kc4 {
>7:32; d34; =0.00; Nb8} Nb8 {4:43; d30; +0.05; Nc3} 56. Nb4 {
>0:04; d32; =0.00; Nd7} Ke4 {2:47; d29; +0.06; Nd3} 57. Nd3 {
>8:25; d34; =0.00; Nd7} Nc6 {0:00; d31; +0.09; Nc5} 58. Nc5+ {
>4:50; d30; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {5:01; d30; +0.06; Nd3} 59. Nd3+ {
>0:02; d33; =0.00; Kf5} Ke4 {0:43; d28; +0.06; Nc5} 60. Nc5+ {
>4:37; d35; =0.00; Ke5} Ke5 {0:17; d31; +0.05; Nd3} 61. Nd3+ {
>2:32; d34; =0.00; Kf5} Kf5 {0:00; d30; +0.05; Nf2} 62. Kd5 {
>0:49; d30; =0.00; Ne7} Na7 {0:51; d26; +0.04; Nf2} 63. Kc5 {
>1:15; d30; =0.00; Nc8} Ke4 {0:13; d17; +0.04; Nf2} 64. Kc4 {
>0:57; d28; =0.00; Nc6} Nc8 {1:01; d26; +0.06; Nc5} 65. Nc5+ {
>0:49; d26; =0.00; Kf4} Kf5 {0:25; d26; +0.06; Kd4} 66. Kd4 {
>0:52; d30; =0.00; Ne7} Nd6 {0:03; d23; +0.06; Kd5} 67. h3 {
>0:48; d28; =0.00; Kf4} g4 {1:03; d26; +0.02; Nd3} 68. hxg4+ {
>0:43; d26; =0.00; Kxg4} Kxg4 {0:02; d15; +0.06; Nd3} 69. Nd3 {
>0:42; d30; =0.00; Nc8} Nf7 {0:15; d30; +0.01; Ke4} 70. Kd5 {
>0:53; d33; =0.00; Kg3} Kf5 {0:47; d30; +0.01; Kd4} 71. Kd4 {
>1:12; d32; =0.00; Ne5} Kg4 {0:00; d32; +0.01; Ke3} 72. Ke3 {
>0:48; d33; =0.00; Ne5} Kg3 {0:09; d31; +0.01; Ne1} 73. Nf4 {
>0:43; d33; =0.00; h3} Ne5 {0:41; d31; +0.01; Ke4} 74. Ke4 {
>0:57; d31; =0.00; Nc6} Nf7 {0:00; d32; +0.01; Nh5} 75. Kf5 {
>0:47; d33; =0.00; Nd6} Nd6+ {0:10; d31; +0.01; Kg5} 76. Ke5 {
>0:23; d30; =0.00; Nc4} Nc4+ {1:43; d30; +0.01; Kf5} 77. Ke4 {
>0:00; d33; =0.00; Nd6} Nd6+ {0:40; d30; +0.01; Ke5} 78. Ke5 {
>0:00; d41; =0.00; Nc4} Nc4+ {0:11; d29; +0.01; Kf5} 79. Ke4 {
>0:49; d44; =0.00; Kf2} Kf2 {0:13; d27; +0.01; Kd4} 80. Kd4 {
>0:28; d29; =0.00; Ne3} Nd2 {0:20; d28; +0.01; Kd5} 81. Kd5 {
>0:58; d30; =0.00; Kg3} Nf1 {0:55; d35; +0.01; Ng6} 82. Kd4 {
>0:28; d26; =0.00; Nd2} Kg3 {0:56; d35; +0.01; Ke4} 83. Ke4 {
>0:41; d33; =0.00; Nd2} Kf2 {0:24; d34; +0.01; Ng6} 84. Kf5 {
>0:53; d28; =0.00; Ne3} Ne3+ {0:38; d69; +0.01; Kg5} 85. Kg5 {
>0:00; d33; =0.00; Nxg2} Nxg2 {0:00; d99; +0.01; Nxg2} 86. Kg4 {
>0:22; d37; =0.00; Nxf4} Ne3+ {0:02; d21; =0.00; Kxh4} 87. Kxh4 {
>0:23; d43; =0.00; Kf3} Ke1 {0:00; d4; =0.00; Ne6} 88. Nd3+ {
>0:24; d49; =0.00; Ke2} Kd1 {0:00; d4; =0.00} 1/2-1/2
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.