Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Yes,this game must stay in the chess history of 'crappy father games

Author: A. Steen

Date: 16:45:29 11/23/05

Go up one level in this thread


On November 23, 2005 at 10:04:47, Dr. Wael Deeb wrote:

>....are you seriously recommneding to save your games as an exeptional ones?If
>you speak seriously,you must proceed for a serious psyheatric check up my
>friend!!

While it is extreme and unacceptable to suggest that a psychiatric remedy may be
needed, I too find these games a little distasteful.

Novices and patzers (i.e., as far as I have sampled to date, the local
population) may think they actually are learning something chessical from these
miscellaneous oscillations. :(

Perhaps this nouveau "chess knowledge" makes such claim that GM Kasimdzhanov's
brilliancy on move 26 of his round 1 match vs Hydra at Bilbao was a blunder, or
a prelude to a suicidal attack, etc.  In fact it leads to a safe draw provided
K. does not blunder.

But I digress.  Back to these oscillations!  It is a psychiatric fact, and I
speak with some knowledge here, that contemplating monotonical oscillatory
movements with certain frequencies can induce a variety of disturbances. :)

However, you may have overlooked that there is a small benefit from this type of
unchessical thing.

"Father" is costing these chess engines "points". :)

Maybe this will in some way result in pressure on authors to eventually work to
ensure that their programs deal with these issues -
clock-handling in closed positions
avoiding closed positions
breaking out of closed positions, sacrificing if necessary

[D]6rk/3bb2q/np1p2rn/1NpPp2p/1PP1PpP1/P2Q3P/1R3NP1/3BBRK1 w - - 0 30

What, for example, could make any reasonable player think that the above
position is "+= or better for white"?  Just look at what is bearing down on the
hapless WK.

These oscillations!

What do you think, both of the positive aspects of these "chess" games (i.e., to
motivate authors) and of the negative (see above).

Best,

A.S.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.