Author: Uri Blass
Date: 08:35:47 12/15/05
Go up one level in this thread
On December 15, 2005 at 11:29:02, Uri Blass wrote: >On December 15, 2005 at 10:56:28, Tord Romstad wrote: > >>On December 15, 2005 at 10:13:51, Uri Blass wrote: >> >>>I read that Dieter claimed that the ecmgcp test suite contains too many >>>sacrifices and he prefers the arasan test suites so I wonder if you tried to >>>compare results in this test. >> >>I just tried the Arasan 5 test suite, and got a result of 67/141 at 10 seconds >>per position. This doesn't look good, but I have no idea how difficult these >>positions really are. What scores are normal for other programs? > >I do not know what scores are normal for other programs because I test only >movei in ecmgcp and arasan but when I compare with movei your result in arasan >is relatively worse than your result in ECMGCP and movei needs more than 20 >seconds to get your ECMGCP results in A3000 when it needs only slighly more than >10 seconds to get you arasan result. > >I do not know exact times because I considered solution as correct only if movei >did not change it's mind later so the number of solutions in x seconds may be >slightly higher if I give movei more time. > >For the record > >Movei in ECMGCP > >solved in less than 2000 solved=147 >solved in less than 2050 solved=147 >solved in less than 2100 solved=147 >solved in less than 2150 45 solved=148 >solved in less than 2200 26 solved=149 >solved in less than 2250 solved=149 >solved in less than 2300 31 solved=150 >solved in less than 2350 solved=150 >solved in less than 2400 149 solved=151 >solved in less than 2450 solved=151 >solved in less than 2500 solved=151 >solved in less than 2550 142 solved=152 > > >Movei in arasan(you need to add 1 to the number of solutions in arasan) >because my program to calculate number of solution has a bug and do not consider >bm with 2 solutions and considered 51 as wrong only because movei changed it's >mind from Nexf6 to Ngxf6) > >1n3rn1/3b4/rq1P1pkp/1p4p1/p1p1N1N1/2Q2B1P/1P3PP1/R3R1K1 w - - bm Nexf6 Ngxf6; id >"arasan4.51"; > >solved in less than 900 124 solved=62 >solved in less than 950 123 solved=63 >solved in less than 1000 104 solved=64 >solved in less than 1050 solved=64 >solved in less than 1100 110 solved=65 >solved in less than 1150 0 solved=66 >solved in less than 1200 solved=66 >solved in less than 1250 solved=66 >solved in less than 1300 solved=66 >solved in less than 1350 16 133 solved=68 >solved in less than 1400 34 113 solved=70 > > > >Uri some more notes I guess that you guess it correctly but solved in less than 1200 means solved in less than 12 seconds. My A3000 is athlon64 2 ghz that is certainly faster than PIV 2.4 ghz and I guess that it is almost twice faster than it(I remember in WCCC that it was near 1.5 times faster than faster pentiumIV). Uri Uri
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.