Author: Uri Blass
Date: 12:43:11 12/17/05
Go up one level in this thread
On December 17, 2005 at 15:27:51, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>On December 17, 2005 at 15:20:24, Uri Blass wrote:
>
>>On December 17, 2005 at 15:08:03, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>>
>>>[Event "60m + 15s, unrated"]
>>>[Site "CSS Online Masters 2006"]
>>>[Date "2005.12.17"]
>>>[Round "?"]
>>>[White "Schwartmann, Fruit 05/11/03 Fish"]
>>>[Black "Romanzev, Rybka 1.0 Beta"]
>>>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>>>[ECO "A88"]
>>>[PlyCount "146"]
>>>[EventDate "2005.12.17"]
>>>[EventType "rapid"]
>>>
>>>1. d4 {0} d6 {(Nf6) 0} 2. Nf3 {0} g6 {(Bg4) 0} 3. c4 {0} f5 {(Nf6) 0} 4. Nc3 {0
>>>} Nf6 {0} 5. g3 {0} Bg7 {0} 6. Bg2 {0} O-O {0} 7. O-O {0} c6 {(Qe8) 0} 8. d5 {0
>>>} e5 {0} 9. dxe6 {0} Bxe6 {0} 10. Qd3 {0} Ng4 {(Na6) 0} 11. Ng5 {0} Bc8 {
>>>0.24/15 116} 12. e4 {(Lf4) 0} Na6 {0.00/14 82} 13. Qe2 {(h3) 0} Re8 {
>>>-0.17/15 158} 14. Rd1 {(f3) -0.47/16 272} h6 {-0.13/15 76} 15. Nf3 {
>>>-0.65/16 102} fxe4 {-0.28/16 42} 16. Nd4 {-0.59/16 63} e3 {(Nf6) -0.38/16 128}
>>>17. fxe3 {-0.31/16 196} Rf8 {-0.40/16 0} 18. Ne4 {(Sf3) -0.34/16 223} Qe7 {
>>>-0.73/15 88} 19. h3 {-0.38/16 72} Nc5 {(Ne5) -0.98/16 5} 20. Nxc5 {-0.68/17 147
>>>} dxc5 {-0.81/17 0} 21. Nxc6 {-0.86/17 127} bxc6 {-1.07/18 0} 22. hxg4 {
>>>-0.81/17 57} Qc7 {-0.96/17 50} 23. Bd2 {-0.82/17 60} Qxg3 {-0.95/17 79} 24. Be1
>>>{-0.57/18 18} Qxg4 {-1.03/17 49} 25. Qxg4 {-0.55/19 108} Bxg4 {-0.98/19 0} 26.
>>>Rd6 {-0.55/19 145} Rf6 {-0.69/18 198} 27. Rxc6 {-0.44/20 0} Rxc6 {-0.69/18 54}
>>>28. Bxc6 {-0.35/20 99} Rb8 {-0.83/20 0} 29. Bd5+ {-0.51/20 103} Kh8 {
>>>(Kh7) -0.90/20 0} 30. Rb1 {-0.44/20 116} Rxb2 {-0.92/22 0} 31. Rxb2 {
>>>-0.65/22 104} Bxb2 {-0.98/23 0} 32. Bg3 {-0.67/23 197} Kg7 {-1.00/23 0} 33. Bb8
>>>{-0.59/23 119} a6 {(Ba3) -1.06/22 0} 34. Bd6 {(Lb7) -0.69/20 59} Ba3 {
>>>-1.09/22 104} 35. e4 {-0.71/22 0} g5 {-1.13/21 63} 36. Kg2 {(Lb7) -0.85/21 45}
>>>h5 {(Kg6) Schwartmann reconnected. -1.14/21 84} 37. e5 {(Lb7) -0.87/23 124} Kg6
>>>{-1.19/21 70} 38. Bc7 {(e6) -0.89/21 24} Bd7 {(Bb2) -1.17/20 89} 39. e6 {
>>>-0.83/21 78} Be8 {-1.19/21 46} 40. Bd8 {-0.77/21 131} Kf5 {-1.19/23 0} 41. Be7
>>>{-0.84/21 50} Bb4 {-1.19/23 47} 42. Kg1 {(Kg3) -0.86/22 112} a5 {-1.19/22 76}
>>>43. Kg2 {-0.88/23 9} h4 {-1.19/22 59} 44. Kh2 {(Ld8) -0.92/23 30} Bh5 {
>>>(Bd2) Schwartmann reconnected. -1.19/22 69} 45. Kg2 {(Kh3) -0.88/21 52} Bg6 {
>>>-1.19/22 96} 46. Kh2 {(Ld8) -0.93/23 0} Be8 {-1.19/23 85} 47. Kg2 {-1.04/23 7}
>>>a4 {-1.19/23 48} 48. Kh2 {(Kf2) -0.98/22 6} Bg6 {(Bc3) -1.19/22 59} 49. Kg2 {
>>>(Kh3) -0.88/22 50} Ba3 {(Bh5) -1.19/23 131} 50. Kh3 {(Ld6) -0.86/21 57} Bh5 {
>>>-1.19/23 75} 51. Kh2 {(Ld6) -0.80/22 0} Bb4 {(Bb2) -1.19/23 72} 52. Kg2 {
>>>(Ld6) -0.83/21 72} Bg6 {(Bg4) -1.19/23 73} 53. Kh2 {(Kh3) -0.87/23 82} Bc3 {
>>>(Be8) -1.19/21 56} 54. Bxc5 {-0.78/21 48} g4 {-1.19/22 36} 55. Bb7 {
>>>(e7) -0.78/20 14} Be5+ {-1.19/21 96} 56. Kg1 {-0.79/22 0} h3 {(Be8) -1.19/21 49
>>>} 57. e7 {-0.79/19 46} Be8 {-1.19/22 72} 58. Kf1 {(a3) -0.79/21 0} Kf6 {
>>>(Bg3) -0.79/17 77} 59. Bc8 {-0.64/19 43} Kg5 {-0.80/18 41} 60. Ba6 {
>>>(Le6) -0.63/20 0} Kg6 {-0.50/17 62} 61. Bc8 {-0.60/20 2} Kh5 {(h2) -0.50/18 42}
>>>62. Ba6 {-0.60/20 77} h2 {-0.50/19 0} 63. Bb7 {-0.61/20 93} Kg5 {
>>>(Kg6) -0.50/20 0} 64. Kg2 {-0.60/20 36} Kf6 {-0.50/22 19} 65. Be4 {
>>>(Kf1) -0.57/21 19} Bb8 {(Bf4) -0.50/21 40} 66. Bb4 {(Ld5) -0.51/22 49} Bc7 {
>>>(Bf4) -0.50/23 65} 67. Bd5 {(La3) -0.51/20 66} Be5 {-0.50/22 234} 68. Kh1 {
>>>(Lb7) -0.50/23 0} Bg3 {(Bf4) -0.50/22 35} 69. Kg2 {-0.50/22 42} Bc7 {-0.50/23 0
>>>} 70. Bc5 {-0.50/21 62} Bf4 {-0.49/23 220} 71. Bb4 {(Lb7) -0.50/23 0} Bd7 {
>>>-0.50/20 33} 72. Be4 {(c5) -0.50/21 42} Bc7 {-0.28/23 664} 73. Ba3 {
>>>(Lb7) -0.50/24 0} Be8 {(Lag: Av=0.57s, max=6.8s) -0.49/21 35} 1/2-1/2
>>
>>both evaluations show advantage for black so why draw.
>>
>>It seems to be decision of humans.
>>The position is drawn but there is no reason to accept draw for a computer.
>>
>>Uri
>
>I not agree. Here can only a engine win in a timetrouble like Bullet, if?
>That is not a reason play Comp. Chessgames!
One engine may also win because of some bug and we are not going to find the bug
if we do not let the game to continue.
My opinion is that a draw should be offered or accepted only by programs and not
by humans.
Uri
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.