Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Spike-Rybka -From Expert To IM-

Author: Vasik Rajlich

Date: 09:49:56 12/28/05

Go up one level in this thread


On December 28, 2005 at 04:17:06, Rolf Tueschen wrote:

>On December 28, 2005 at 03:12:23, Vasik Rajlich wrote:
>
>>Interesting game. I didn't like .. h6 and .. g5 by Rybka in the opening (as I
>>suspect most human players won't), and there were a few moments in the endgame
>>where better resistance could have been put up - but these are relatively minor
>>points.
>>
>>The biggest issue was the incorrect sacrifice of the h6 pawn. The Rybka static
>>eval incorrectly gives the following position (and others of a similar type) as
>>roughly equal:
>>
>>[D] 8/1b2b1k1/pp1ppp2/nPq5/P1P1P3/2QRNPP1/8/1N2KB1r b - - 0 27
>>
>>I'll keep to myself my proposed solution. It's a tricky issue and won't be
>>handled until after the Rybka 1.2 release. If anybody wants to share here, I am
>>all ears :-)
>>
>>Vas
>
>
>I'm just an expert player and have plenty of weaknesses you as IM surely dont
>have. But I know how I would see the given position. And excuse me if I
>contradict an IM.
>
>1) Of course this position is good for Black. Period.
>
>2) Of course you cant exchange Queens in such a win/lose position! Period.
>
>3) Rybka is very good. Period.
>
>4) But the restrictions for chess in machine chess will always lead to such a
>nonsense, namely how Rybka destroyed a promissing position. The reason is simply
>the antique, historical, old, well known horizon effect. And there is no trick
>to lead a machine around this obstacle. Not by killer moves nor by nullmoves.
>Therefore - actually and for the next years - there is something wrong in your
>whole approach with the plan for 1.2.
>
>5) There is no trick to avoid the specifical chess Law in computerchess. The
>absolute Power of the Concrete in relation to the always very limited view of
>the machine due to horizon blindness. In the game against Spike every
>experienced player knows that he cant trade Queens in such an open attack
>position.
>
>6) Somewhere also YOU (as experienced and tricky IM) must hide the weakness to
>allow the telling brilliance of Rybka and that will be the key for your
>competitors, talking in engine-engine competition at least.

Rolf --

evidence for black´s advantage is most welcome :)

Vas



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 07 Jul 11 08:48:38 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.