Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Rybla 11 slightly broken?

Author: enrico carrisco

Date: 17:34:17 01/22/06

Go up one level in this thread


On January 22, 2006 at 16:38:53, Mike Byrne wrote:

>Under Arena GUI
>
>Results here also indicate that there may something wrong with Rybka 11 when
>compared to Rybka 10d
>

I have seen folks with Rybka 11b and 11c on playchess.com, so I'd imagine there
are some new versions out...

-elc.

>
>
> Engine                      Score     RyShRyRyToRyShGFReZa   S-B
>01: Rybka v1.0 Preview 2 x64    13.5/17 · 0 1 = = = 1 1 1 = 108.50
>02: Shredder 8                  13.0/17 1 · = =   1 = 1 = = 103.25
>03: Rybka v1.01 Beta 9.x64      13.0/17 0 = · = 0 1 1   1 =  97.75
>04: Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64     12.0/17 = = = · = 1   1 1    97.75
>05: Toga II                     12.0/17 =   1 = · = 0 1 0 1  94.00
>06: Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64 MFB 12.0/17 = 0 0 0 = · = 1 1 1  88.25
>07: Shredder 9.1                9.0/17  0 = 0   1 = · 0 = 1  70.50
>08: GFruit-4bx                  9.0/17  0 0   0 0 0 1 · = 1  59.00
>09: Rebel 12                    8.0/17  0 = 0 0 1 0 = = · 1  60.25
>10: Zappa 1.1                   8.0/17  = = =   0 0 0 0 0 ·  59.00
>11: TheKing 3.23                7.5/17  0 = 0 0 0 0 0 =   1  50.75
>12: Ruffian 2.1                 7.5/17  0 0 0 0 =   = 0 = 0  49.50
>13: Deep Sjeng 1.6              7.0/17  =   0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0  56.25
>14: Fruit 2.1                   6.0/17  0 =   0 0 0 1 = = 1  47.25
>15: Gandalf60                   6.0/17  0 = 0 0 = 0 0 0   0  43.25
>16: Pro Deo                     6.0/17  0 0 0 = = 0     = 0  40.50
>17: Crafty64 19.20              5.5/17  0 0 0 =   0 = = = =  41.50
>18: Shredder Classic 1.3        5.5/17  0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 = 0  34.50
>19: AnMon 5.50                  5.0/17    0 0 = 0 = = 0 0    37.50
>20: SOS 5.1 for Arena           4.5/17    0 = = 0   0 0 0 0  33.25
>
> Engine                      Score     ThRuDeFrGaPrCrShAnSO   S-B
>01: Rybka v1.0 Preview 2 x64    13.5/17 1 1 = 1 1 1 1 1     108.50
>02: Shredder 8                  13.0/17 = 1   = = 1 1 1 1 1 103.25
>03: Rybka v1.01 Beta 9.x64      13.0/17 1 1 1   1 1 1 1 1 =  97.75
>04: Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64     12.0/17 1 1 0 1 1 = = 1 = =  97.75
>05: Toga II                     12.0/17 1 = 1 1 = =   1 1 1  94.00
>06: Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64 MFB 12.0/17 1   1 1 1 1 1 1 =    88.25
>07: Shredder 9.1                9.0/17  1 = 1 0 1   = 0 = 1  70.50
>08: GFruit-4bx                  9.0/17  = 1 0 = 1   = 1 1 1  59.00
>09: Rebel 12                    8.0/17    = 0 =   = = = 1 1  60.25
>10: Zappa 1.1                   8.0/17  0 1 1 0 1 1 = 1   1  59.00
>11: TheKing 3.23                7.5/17  · = = = 1 =   1 = 1  50.75
>12: Ruffian 2.1                 7.5/17  = · 1 1 0 1 =   1 1  49.50
>13: Deep Sjeng 1.6              7.0/17  = 0 · 1 0 1 0   = =  56.25
>14: Fruit 2.1                   6.0/17  = 0 0 ·   1 1 0 0 0  47.25
>15: Gandalf60                   6.0/17  0 1 1   · = 1 = 1 0  43.25
>16: Pro Deo                     6.0/17  = 0 0 0 = · = 1 1 1  40.50
>17: Crafty64 19.20              5.5/17    = 1 0 0 = · 0 = =  41.50
>18: Shredder Classic 1.3        5.5/17  0     1 = 0 1 · = 1  34.50
>19: AnMon 5.50                  5.0/17  = 0 = 1 0 0 = = · =  37.50
>20: SOS 5.1 for Arena           4.5/17  0 0 = 1 1 0 = 0 = ·  33.25
>
>170 of 760 games played
>Name of the tournament: Blitz_5_5_QUAD RR_2_c
>Site/ Country: WIN-64-MB, United States
>Level: Blitz 5/5
>Hardware: Dual AMD Opteron(tm) Processor 244 1804 MHz with 2,046 MB Memory
>Operating system: Microsoft Windows Server 2003 Professional Service Pack 1
>(Build 3790)
>
>1/22/2006 4:26:24 PM :
>
>   Program                      Elo   +   - Games Score Av.Op.Draws
>
> 1 Rybka v1.0 Preview 2 x64     2860 170 152  17  79.4 % 2626 29.4 %
> 2 Rybka v1.01 Beta 9.x64       2818 179 164  17  76.5 % 2613 23.5 %
> 3 Shredder 8                   2809 143 102  17  76.5 % 2604 47.1 %
> 4 Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64 MFB  2776 169 159  17  70.6 % 2624 23.5 %
> 5 Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64      2763 132 117  17  70.6 % 2611 47.1 %
> 6 Toga II                      2760 150 140  17  70.6 % 2608 35.3 %
> 7 Shredder 9.1                 2637 141 140  17  52.9 % 2616 35.3 %
> 8 GFruit-4bx                   2634 155 153  17  52.9 % 2613 23.5 %
> 9 Rebel 12                     2607 125 126  17  47.1 % 2628 47.1 %
>10 Zappa 1.1                    2601 153 155  17  47.1 % 2622 23.5 %
>11 TheKing 3.23                 2589 132 134  17  44.1 % 2630 41.2 %
>12 Ruffian 2.1                  2579 146 149  17  44.1 % 2620 29.4 %
>13 Deep Sjeng 1.6               2557 153 158  17  41.2 % 2619 23.5 %
>14 Gandalf60                    2527 155 163  17  35.3 % 2632 23.5 %
>15 Pro Deo                      2519 140 146  17  35.3 % 2624 35.3 %
>16 Fruit 2.1                    2514 155 163  17  35.3 % 2620 23.5 %
>17 Shredder Classic 1.3         2504 164 175  17  32.4 % 2633 17.6 %
>18 Crafty64 19.20               2493 108 123  17  32.4 % 2621 52.9 %
>19 AnMon 5.50                   2464 117 132  17  29.4 % 2616 47.1 %
>20 SOS 5.1 for Arena            2430 151 162  17  26.5 % 2607 29.4 %
>
>Rybka 10d results - note how some the top programs (Rybka Preview/Shredder8)were
>generlly pushed down in ratings when 10d was in the torunament,
>1/22/2006 4:23:34 PM :
>
>   Program                      Elo   +   - GamesScore Av.Op.Draws
>
> 1 Rybka v1.01 Beta 10d.x64     2817 128 119  26 76.9 % 2608 30.8 %
> 2 Rybka v1.01 Beta 10d.x64 MFB 2787 125 119  26 73.1 % 2614 30.8 %
> 3 Rybka v1.0 Preview 2 x64     2763 123 117  26 69.2 % 2622 30.8 %
> 4 Rybka v1.01 Beta 9.x64       2726 112 108  26 65.4 % 2615 38.5 %
> 5 Shredder 8                   2695 111 108  26 61.5 % 2613 38.5 %
> 6 Toga II                      2657  98  96  26 55.8 % 2617 50.0 %
> 7 GFruit-4bx                   2652 113 111  26 55.8 % 2612 34.6 %
> 8 Rebel 12                     2644 116 115  26 53.8 % 2617 30.8 %
> 9 Fruit 2.1                    2637 116 115  26 53.8 % 2611 30.8 %
>10 Gandalf60                    2619 101 101  26 50.0 % 2619 46.2 %
>11 Ruffian 2.1                  2602 104 105  26 48.1 % 2615 42.3 %
>12 Zappa 1.1                    2601 104 105  26 48.1 % 2614 42.3 %
>13 Shredder 9.1                 2585 115 116  26 46.2 % 2612 30.8 %
>14 Pro Deo                      2571 108 109  26 42.3 % 2625 38.5 %
>15 Shredder Classic 1.3         2570 115 117  26 42.3 % 2624 30.8 %
>16 Deep Sjeng 1.6               2539 112 114  26 40.4 % 2607 34.6 %
>17 TheKing 3.23                 2523 112 115  26 36.5 % 2619 34.6 %
>18 SOS 5.1 for Arena            2493 113 117  26 32.7 % 2618 34.6 %
>19 Crafty64 19.20               2438 135 144  26 25.0 % 2629 19.2 %
>20 AnMon 5.50                   2421 132 141  26 23.1 % 2630 23.1 %
>
> Program                      R11   R10D
>
> AnMon 5.50                   2464  2421
> Crafty64 19.20               2493  2438
> Deep Sjeng 1.6               2557  2539
> Fruit 2.1                    2514  2637
> Gandalf60                    2527  2619
> GFruit-4bx                   2634  2652
> Pro Deo                      2519  2571
> Rebel 12                     2607  2644
> Ruffian 2.1                  2579  2602
> Rybka v1.0 Preview 2 x64     2860  2763
> Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64      2763
> Rybka v1.01 Beta 11.x64 MFB  2776
> Rybka v1.01 Beta 10d.x64           2817
> Rybka v1.01 Beta 10d.x64 MFB       2787
> Rybka v1.01 Beta 9.x64       2818  2726
> Shredder 8                   2809  2695
> Shredder 9.1                 2637  2585
> Shredder Classic 1.3         2504  2570
> SOS 5.1 for Arena            2430  2493
> TheKing 3.23                 2589  2523
> Toga II                      2760  2657
> Zappa 1.1                    2601  2601



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.