Author: Per Jørgensen
Date: 01:02:29 03/06/06
Go up one level in this thread
On March 06, 2006 at 03:30:31, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>On March 05, 2006 at 18:37:09, Chessfun wrote:
>
>>CCRL: 40/40 Adapted to Athlon 64 3800+
>>
>>
>>ChessTiger 2004 v Toga II 1.1a +3 -10 =17
>>
>>Games available in next rating list update.
>>
>>Current rating lists, statistics and games.
>>http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/
>>
>>Sarah
>
>Thanks for testing Sarah!
>
>Question: Why is Hiarcs 10 hypermodern on place 4 and Toga II 1.1a only on place
>5?
>
>See here:
>
>4 Hiarcs 10 Hypermodern 2832 +27 −27 55.4% 2799.3 41.8% 400
>5 Toga II 1.1a 2832 +24 −24 55.4% 2797.2 36.9% 558
>
>
>1. Toga played more games.
>2. the score difference by Toga is only +24 -24, by Hiarcs 10 +27 -27, also
>weaker then Toga!
>
>I my eyes Toga 1.1a should be now on place 4. Where I am wrong?
>
>Best,
>Ed.
Hello Ed!
In my opinion Hiarcs 10 (with or without Hypermodern ON) and Toga II 1.1a are
very equal regarding playingstrength. I guess it depends on the specific
testconditions. In my latest ratinglist Hiarcs 10 with Hypermodern ON is 16
points ahead of Toga II 1.1a:
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Hiarcs 10 2770 35 35 300 65.0 % 2662 26.7 %
2 Fruit 2.2.1 2768 34 34 300 64.8 % 2662 29.0 %
3 Toga II 1.1a 2754 33 33 300 62.8 % 2663 32.3 %
4 Shredder 9 2728 34 34 300 59.0 % 2665 27.3 %
5 Fritz 9 2726 34 34 300 58.7 % 2665 27.3 %
6 Spike 1.1 2709 33 33 300 56.2 % 2666 32.3 %
7 The King 3.33 2673 33 33 300 50.7 % 2668 30.7 %
8 SmarThink 1.00 2659 33 33 300 48.5 % 2669 30.3 %
9 Ktulu 7.5 2655 34 34 300 47.8 % 2670 25.0 %
10 Pro Deo 1.1 2634 34 34 300 44.7 % 2671 25.3 %
11 Gandalf 6.0 2614 33 33 300 41.7 % 2672 30.0 %
12 Junior 9 2613 35 35 300 41.5 % 2672 23.7 %
13 Loop List 600 2609 35 35 300 41.0 % 2673 22.0 %
14 Naum 1.91 2606 32 32 300 40.5 % 2673 33.7 %
15 Glaurung 1.0.1 2597 35 35 300 39.2 % 2674 23.0 %
16 Ruffian 2.1.0 2589 33 33 300 38.0 % 2674 30.7 %
Please check my posting from yesterday for the specific testconditions.
Having said all this there is no doubt at all that Toga II 1.1a is a very strong
engine and with the exception of Rybka beta 1.0 Toga is the strongest Free-ware
engine for the time being followed by Spike 1.1.
Regards
Per
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.