Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Does it Really matter if Computers of GM At 40/2? A subjective Viewpoint

Author: greg moller

Date: 11:41:26 05/04/99

Go up one level in this thread


On May 03, 1999 at 17:56:21, Will Singleton wrote:

>On May 03, 1999 at 14:43:12, Dann Corbit wrote:
>
>>Everyone knows that computers are the best in the world at blitz already...
>
>Well, maybe not. :)
>
>Standard            Blitz               Bullet
>2720 Ferret(C)      3137 Dlugy(GM)      2937 Data(C)
>2720 OzsO(C)        3132 Ferret(C)      2930 WchessX(C)
>2682 matemastr(C)   3101 Mofongo(C)     2914 Mofongo(C)
>2677 RAINHA(C)      3076 FlyingPike(GM) 2912 crafty(C)
>2676 Lynnett(C)     3058 crafty(C)      2855 Box(C)
<snip>

I wouldn't trust the blitz ratings on ICC. This is a place where most players
duck one another all the time, handpick their opponents and only play each other
when the rating differential seems favorable. All this has a negative impact on
the rating system's accuracy.

ICC should implement a system whereby it _forces_ players to regularly play
others in their rating bracket, possibly by generating random server pairings,
whenever a player's open for matches, in order to keep their ratings active AND
accurate at the same time. At the moment ratings seem dictated by players' whims
rather than their strength. Over-inflation at the top is clearly one of the
farcical by-products, although there may be other factors contributing to that.

Also, the list shown above is subjective (as the header suggests). Ratings can
change very fast(another fallacy) on ICC, and picking a random top-ranking list
could just as likely show a Computer on top.
Incidentally, to find out the 'best' blitz players list, don't use the _best_
command, which only gives human players (and then not all of those, either), but
use the _rank_ <playername> command, just as Will (correctly) did.

Regards,
gm




This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.