Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: 1989 opinion poll and idea for new poll question

Author: Robert Hyatt

Date: 14:31:57 07/15/99

Go up one level in this thread


On July 15, 1999 at 00:27:47, Peter Kappler wrote:

>On July 14, 1999 at 16:25:12, Robert Hyatt wrote:
>
>>On July 14, 1999 at 15:13:59, Peter Hegger wrote:
>>
>>>Hello
>>>In 1989, at the world computer chess championship in Edmonton, David Levy asked
>>>participants:
>>>"In what year do you think a chess program will be able to defeat the human
>>>world champion?"
>>>Here are the answers.
>>>Year    Names
>>>1992    Gyula Horvath, Monty Newborn
>>>1993    John McCarthy
>>>1994    Hans Berliner, Marty Hirsch, Feng-hsuing Hsu
>>>1995    Murray Campbell, Larry Kaufmann, David Kittinger, Danny Kopec, Donald
>>>       Mitchie, David Slate, Mike Valvo
>>>1997    John Stanbeck
>>>1998    Kevin O'connell
>>>1999    Ed Felton, Tom Pronk, Sidney Samole, Claude Shannon, Jos Uiterwijk
>>>2000    Robert Hyatt, GM Kevin Spraggett, Victor Vikhrev, Jaap van den Herik
>>>2001    Jurg Nivergelt, Mark Taylor
>>>2002    IM Julio Kaplan
>>>2005    Richard Lang, Pierre Nolet, Ard van Bergen
>>>2008    Harry Nelson
>>>2010    Don Dailey, Ossi Weiner
>>>2011    Lars Hjorth
>>>2013    Tony Scherzer
>>>2014    David Levy
>>>2020    Tony Marsland
>>>2025    Dap Hartmann
>>>2030    Franz Morsch
>>>2040    Jonathan Schaeffer
>>>2050    Harm Bakker
>>>2056    Helmut Horacek
>>>NEVER   David Cahlander
>>>
>>>The mean average of these predictions is the year 2005.
>>>I thought it might be interesting to formulate a new opinion poll question
>>>asking "In what year do you think a computer chess program will be able to
>>>defeat the human world champion in a 20 game 40/2 match?"
>>>Any feedback is welcome.
>>>Regards
>>>Peter
>>
>>
>>I'd answer 1998.  I think DB would have beaten Kasparov in 20 games just
>>as it did in 6 games.  He already had a fork stuck in him by game 5.  He
>>was "done" I think...
>
>
>Surely this would not have been your prediction before that match...
>
>--Peter



Nope... I originally guessed 2000.  And thought before the match that Kasparov
would win.  But DB II was _much_ better than DB I.  And with "hindsight" I think
DB would have won a 20 game match.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.