Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: What's a good strong stand alone?

Author: eric guttenberg

Date: 23:40:31 09/08/99

Go up one level in this thread


I don't believe you will find any stand-alones that can play at over
2400 USCF. Dedicated chess computers aren't produced anymore with an
eye towards increasing playing strength.  I have a Berlin 68020 that
was advertised as the strongest stand-alone available for less than $1000
when I got it back around 1993. It runs on a 25mhz processor and at that
time most home PC's were only 33 or 50mhz and the best software programs
were only marginally stronger than Berlin and many were weaker.
But then PC's began to get faster and faster and software programmers began
to put more effort into their products and the software programs left
the stand-alones in the dust. My Berlin probably plays about 2350 USCF and
after all these years is probably still as strong or stronger than any
of the current stand-alones.

I think that since the producers of stand-alones know that they simply
cannot compete with any top program on fast hardware in playing strength,
they will not even try.  Instead they will emphasize making the package
as attractive as possible to those users who just like to play with
an actual, 3-dimensional chess set.

Actually, my favorite dedicated chess computer is not the Berlin, but
the Fidelity Premier Elite, which is a full-size, wood, auto-sensory
piece of furniture.  It is a delight to play, strong enough to win an
easy majority of the games I play but is probably only about 2250 USCF.
Berlin is stronger but I think Premier is better in user enjoyment.

It does seem odd that only about 1992 the question in the Computer
Chess Reports was whether software programs on home PC's would ever
be as strong as the best stand-alones. This year I matched the Berlin Pro
68020 at g/30 against Genius 5, Hiarcs 7.32, CM6000, and Fritz 5.32
on my Celeron 333mhz and got respectively 16-0, 4 draws; 17-0, 3 draws;
18-0, 2 draws; and 27-0, 3 draws. The only reason I played so many games
was that I wanted to see if Berlin would ever win one. I finally gave
up.

eric



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.