Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Rating question

Author: Micheal Cummings

Date: 07:20:21 09/09/99

Go up one level in this thread


On September 09, 1999 at 07:27:15, Sune Larsson wrote:

>Well, I have this try with Crafty1615 and a friend of mine - ELO 2300.
>Yes 40 moves in 2 hours. 400Mhz pentium, books and everything, but..
>First 4 games no problems - hard combat and 2-2. But afterwards, we had agreed
>10 games... Yeah a little money, prestige and stuff, you know...
>My computer hangs up, crashes and believe it or not - 6 times in a row!
>How things can happen...
>Problems arises - my friend want to call it a win for him 8-2, due to the
>argument "if you don't play - you lose"
>
>Need help - what to do ? And my rating for Crafty vs ELO 2300, should it
>be calculated from this 2-8?  But really they didn't play the last 6 games -
>just 20-30 moves... Need perspective.  Maybe from Australia...
>
>Sune :)

Well it depends on your friend. You could play these games again. But since
money is involved I suppose that he has some small right to call the win. But if
I was playing a friend I would not take them as wins. So I just wonder how good
a friend he is ?

I just think he is only interested in the money. Otherwise to count six games
cause of a computer crash as wins is pretty weak. If it happened one time or was
something on the scale of what Ed and Rebel have been doing, then I would say
count it as a loss. But there is no pride in winning over a program that
continually stuffs up.

One or maybe two stuff ups take the loss. But three or more, just reply the
games.

I would feel like a greedy scum bag if I took the money cause a computer crashed
six times. Tell him to go jump, either play the 6 crashed games again, or the
bet is off.

That is unless of course the crashes happened when crafty was beaten anyway.




This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.