Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: What is the best program for annalyzing and annotating games?

Author: Pete Galati

Date: 15:03:24 11/18/99

Go up one level in this thread


On November 18, 1999 at 17:07:38, Seth Hodgkins wrote:

>I currently have chessmaster6000 which I feel is alright for annalyzing my
>games.  It seems to poing out when I made a less then perfect move but it never
>really tells why a move is bad or give me insight about my game as a whole i.e.
>where my strengths and weaknesses may be?  Maybe I'm looking for a program that
>doesn't exist?  I've been thinking about buying Fritz 6.0 when it comes out.
>The company touts a very good analysis and annotative abilities, but you know
>how that goes.  I'm sure there is some bias involved; they are trying to sell
>their product? I'd really appreciate it if someone with experience with some of
>the professional programs on the market could tell me what the best program is
>that matches some of the features I'm looking for.I.E. superb annotating(voice
>preferred) and analysis. Or at least to let me know if I'm wasting my time
>looking for something thats not really on the market.

There really aren't any programs that will sit you down in a chair and explain
things to you in English.  The program really has no idea what's happening, it's
just calculating out a series of moves that can be made from each position, and
that's what the program is reporting to you about.

I prefer Crafty for annotating games even though it does not have a fancy gui to
walk you though getting it done.  I'd probably never buy a program for it's
ability to annotate a game since for the most part Fritz _very_ often comes to
the same conclusions as the free Crafty does.

I think that you can find annotated games by Fritz that you can take a look at
and see if you like how it annotates games, try the Tacky Patser site, I bet
Jeroem has some, http://home.wxs.nl/~jimvandorp/  or look at usenet group
news:rec.games.chess.computer  because someone has recently done a post about
"Friterized" games, this might give you a good idea what Fritz annotates like.

Pete



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.