Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Top engines fail to found obvious best move! A good test position!

Author: Dave Gomboc

Date: 21:34:36 11/24/99

Go up one level in this thread


I guess this means that programs are still making progress... :)

Dave

On November 25, 1999 at 00:28:55, Martin Grabriel wrote:

>I love these posts.
>Using the Rebel10 engine on epd2diag, Rebel 10 started looking at Bf5xh3 after
>about 3 mins, confirmed that it is Bf5xh3 in 11 mins 4 secs, and then gave the
>line below in about 19 mins 59 secs :
>
>19:59  08.16  0.41  Bf5xh3 g2xh3 Qd7xh3 Ra1-c1 Nf6-g4 Nc3-e4 Ng4xe3
>
>
>Hardware : PII 350 Mhz, 32 Mb Ram (running simultaneously many things like lotus
>notes, Ms Word, etc.)
>and the engine was only given 2 Mb ram for use under epd2diag.
>
>I don't have Rebel Century, I think it will do even better.
>
>
>
>On November 24, 1999 at 22:42:52, yibing fan wrote:
>
>>This position was rearched after white's 15th move in a game between
>>Duz_Hotimirsky F I  - Yudovich Mikhail M, 1948. Black to move. The game only
>>lasted 20 moves.
>>
>>3r1rk1/p2q1ppp/2pb1n2/5b2/1nB5/2N1BN1P/PP2QPP1/R4RK1 b - - id=Duz_Hotimirsky F I
>> - Yudovich Mikhail M ; bm=f5h3;
>>
>>All my top chess softwares failed to find the best move BxP(h3) within 8 hrs
>>search on a PII 266.  I tried crafty 16.6, Rebel 8, CM6000. Try yours!  It is a
>>good position to keep your chess engine busy for whole Thanksgiving holidays!
>>
>>Rebel 8 eventually came up with the best move after ~16 hrs seaching!
>>It reach this conclusion after evaluated ~150 million positions. Before that, it
>>prefers Rfe8 pinning white Queen.
>>
>>Crafty on the other hand eveluated >500 million positions and still perfered
>>Nc2.
>>(Sorry Bob, I terminated search after about 10 hrs, It may came up with the same
>>conclusion as rebel 8 if I gave it another 10 hrs.)
>>CM6000 also prefers Nc2.
>>
>>It is not suprising or new that computer miss best moves, what it surprised me
>>is that they miss such obvious (for human at least) one.  I am a club player, I
>>have no problem to see BxP and to win against any above software at this
>>position. The reason to play BxP is simple, here is how I think: after bishop
>>for two pawns, white K is traped. white's N, f-pawn and Q is terribly tied
>>togeter; other white pieces are just too far away to save their King. On the
>>contrast, black enjoys direct attack with his Q, N and B; He also has a reserved
>>Rook to deliver final KO if neccessary.  You don't need a lot calculations, just
>>make sure not make a terrible blunder. Go for it!
>>
>>Unfortunately, none of those software can think this way. In addition, I think
>>this position is more of tactic than positional.
>>
>>Bob, Ed you may want to add this position into your testing suite.
>>
>>By the way, I like both your programs, they are excellent for analyse my games.
>>
>>Yibing Fan



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.