Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Unfair Prejudice Against Computers?

Author: Graham Laight

Date: 18:39:33 01/02/00

Go up one level in this thread


On January 02, 2000 at 09:32:50, Albert Silver wrote:

>On January 01, 2000 at 16:53:00, Graham Laight wrote:
>>Imagine if human players from a particular country were told that they may not
>>play against strong players unless they were prepared to pay high fees for
>>individual games.
>>
>>There would, quite rightly, be an outcry!
>>
>>It's unfair on the computers to put these restrictions on them. Where's your
>>humanity?  :-)
>>
>>-g
>
>It isn't quite the same thing you know, but being a CC enthusiast, I naturally
>want to see the games take place. The real changes took place when the computers
>came into a position to win tournaments. That's when they were more truly
>stonewalled. I remember a huge, 11 round, 30 minute game open in France at
>Aubervilliers, and there was always an interesting roster of computer players
>participating. I haven't heard about any computer participation since a version
>of Genius tied for 2nd-3rd though. I can understand as well, and it is
>complicated. Would you want to participate in a tournament (active chess) with
>IMs, GMs, and tons of players, and have the results read like this:
>
>1) Fritz 9.99       10.5/11
>2-4) Hiarcs 10.0    10/11
>2-4) Rebel Timewarp 10/11
>2-4) Chess Weasel   10/11
>5-9) CM 9300        9.5/11
>5-9) Nimzo 9.64     9.5/11
>5-9) Deeper Junior  9.5/11
>5-9) Crafty 23.412  9.5/11
>5-9) GM Short       9.5/11
>
>Etc...
>
>I sympathize, even if the prizes are given only to the human players. The
>problem will only worsen apart from specially organized events, designed to
>include cybernetic opponents.
>
>                                    Albert Silver

The above text is a wonderful sight to behold!

Albert appears to be admitting that, within 2 new versions of Hiarcs, chess
software will be in a position to push GM Short, the 2nd best player in the UK,
and the player who challenged Kasparov for the PCA world championship just a few
years ago, into 9th place in an active tournament! All we need now is the
confession that they'll also be able to get some points in a proper GM 40/120
event!

-g



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.