Author: José Carlos
Date: 09:26:44 09/23/01
Go up one level in this thread
On September 23, 2001 at 11:51:02, Mike S. wrote: >On September 23, 2001 at 11:13:14, José Carlos wrote: > >>(...) Besides, I belive the "scale" (if we can >>use this term) is smaler in human world than in comp-comp world, meaning that a >>small difference between two versions of a program (or two different programs, >>of course) can appear over and over in games, translating into more and more >>rating points. > >This would be the case only if it's not just a small, but also a decisive >difference, furthermore many programs have position learning. I disagree. Humans are irregular. They can be happy and attack wildly or be sad and lose badly against a weaker opponent, etc. Computers are regular. They always do the same mistakes and the same good moves. Position learning is not enough to prevent this behaviour. You'd need a many Gigs positions file to hide a weak point of a program. Additionally, the "human world" contains many thousands of players, while the comp-comp world is much smaller. I believe that the bigger the pool is, the smaller the scale. Just my opinion, anyway. José C. >But there's another aspect of this type of speed/strength estimation: The faster >program can't be +60 elo (or whatever the value is) stronger at every move in a >game. Actually, many moves will be the same on 400 MHz and on 800 MHz, if this >is the only difference of the conditions. In some positions, moves will be >different but not necessarily stronger (i.e., if there is a number of moves >within a narrow margin of evaluations). Btw. I've heard experiments have been >made, showing that approx. 16% of moves are different if the search is one ply >deeper. > >So I think there is a very small number of moves, maybe only one or two per >game, where the higher speed is decisive for the result. Humans are certainly >more flexible in time consumption, and probably can adapt better to that than >programs. Furthermore, the higher speed affects only parts of a programs >performance. Opening book, egtbs, and parts of what can be described as >knowledge (in human terms) of the program, is the same at all cpu speeds and >time settings. > >Regards, >M.Scheidl
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.